The Story of Edgar Sawtelle: A Novel

  Author:    David Wroblewski
  ISBN:    0061374229
  Sales Rank:    9
  Published:    2008-06-01
  Publisher:    Ecco
  # Pages:    576
  Binding:    Hardcover
  Avg. Rating:    4.0 based on 324 reviews
  Used Offers:    23 from $14.00
  Amazon Price:    $14.27
  (Data above last updated:  2008-09-23 11:05:40 EST)
  
  
Sort customer reviews by:
  
Show All Reviews on Page      Hide All Reviews on Page
   
  
The Story of Edgar Sawtelle: A Novel
  
Amazon Best of the Month, June 2008: It's gutsy for a debut novelist to offer a modern take on Hamlet set in rural Wisconsin--particularly one in which the young hero, born mute, communicates with people, dogs, and the occasional ghost through his own mix of sign and body language. But David Wroblewski's extraordinary way with language in The Story of Edgar Sawtelle immerses readers in a living, breathing world that is both fantastic and utterly believable. In selecting for temperament and a special intelligence, Edgar's grandfather started a line of unusual dogs--the Sawtelles--and his sons carried on his work. But among human families, undesirable traits aren't so easily predicted, and clashes can erupt with tragic force. Edgar's tale takes you to the extremes of what humans must endure, and when you're finally released, you will come back to yourself feeling wiser, and flush with gratitude. And you will have remembered what magnificent alchemy a finely wrought novel can work. --Mari Malcolm


Book Description

Born mute, speaking only in sign, Edgar Sawtelle leads an idyllic life with his parents on their farm in remote northern Wisconsin. For generations, the Sawtelles have raised and trained a fictional breed of dog whose thoughtful companionship is epitomized by Almondine, Edgar's lifelong friend and ally. But with the unexpected return of Claude, Edgar's paternal uncle, turmoil consumes the Sawtelles' once peaceful home. When Edgar's father dies suddenly, Claude insinuates himself into the life of the farm--and into Edgar's mother's affections.

Grief-stricken and bewildered, Edgar tries to prove Claude played a role in his father's death, but his plan backfires--spectacularly. Forced to flee into the vast wilderness lying beyond the farm, Edgar comes of age in the wild, fighting for his survival and that of the three yearling dogs who follow him. But his need to face his father's murderer and his devotion to the Sawtelle dogs turn Edgar ever homeward.

David Wroblewski is a master storyteller, and his breathtaking scenes--the elemental north woods, the sweep of seasons, an iconic American barn, a fateful vision rendered in the falling rain--create a riveting family saga, a brilliant exploration of the limits of language, and a compulsively readable modern classic.

Double Life, with Dogs: An Amazon Exclusive Essay by David Wroblewski

We write the stories we wish we could read. There's no other reason to do it, to spend years pacing around your basement, mumbling, pecking at a keyboard, turning your back on a world that offers such a feast of delicious fruits. The Story of Edgar Sawtelle came about because some time ago I wished I could read a novel about a boy and his dog, one that integrated our contemporary knowledge of canine behavior, cognition, and origins with my experience of living with dogs; if possible, something flavored with the uncynical Midwestern sense of heart and purpose so familiar from my childhood (and something which, in truth, I've spent much my adult life being slightly ashamed of, as if either heart or purpose were embarrassing attributes for a grown-up to display). I'd recently come to know a good dog, maybe the best dog I'd ever met, and the subject of people and dogs and ethics and character suddenly seemed urgent. But when I went looking for such a story, I had to go back almost a hundred years, back to Jack London's Call of the Wild. That was a surprise. A little while after that, an idea for a story came to me--not the whole thing, but enough to start.

Continue Reading Double Life, With Dogs

Praise from Stephen King

"I flat-out loved The Story of Edgar Sawtelle, and spent twelve happy evenings immersed in the world David Wroblewski has created. As I neared the end, I kept finding excuses to put the book aside for a little, not because I didn't like it, but because I liked it too much; I didn't want it to end. Dog-lovers in particular will find themselves riveted by this story, because the canine world has never been explored with such imagination and emotional resonance. Yet in the end, this isn't a novel about dogs or heartland America--although it is a deeply American work of literature. It's a novel about the human heart, and the mysteries that live there, understood but impossible to articulate. Yet in the person of Edgar Sawtelle, a mute boy who takes three of his dogs on a brave and dangerous odyssey, Wroblewski does articulate them, and splendidly. I closed the book with that regret readers feel only after experiencing the best stories: It's over, you think, and I won't read another one this good for a long, long time.

In truth, there's never been a book quite like The Story of Edgar Sawtelle. I thought of Hamlet when I was reading it, and Watership Down, and The Night of the Hunter, and The Life of Pi--but halfway through, I put all comparisons aside and let it just be itself.

I'm pretty sure this book is going to be a bestseller, but unlike some, it deserves to be. It's also going to be the subject of a great many reading groups, and when the members take up Edgar, I think they will be apt to stick to the book and forget the neighborhood gossip.

Wonderful, mysterious, long and satisfying: readers who pick up this novel are going to enter a richer world. I envy them the trip. I don't re-read many books, because life is too short. I will be re-reading this one."

                  Reader Reviews 1 - 50 of 347            Next
  
  
Review
Date
Review
Rating(5 High)
Review
Helpful
to:
Customer Review Reviewer
Info
Permanent
Link
Reader Reviews Below Sorted by Newest First
09-22-08 2 0\1
(Hide Review...)  Had potential and then lost it within a few pages
Reviewer Permalink
(No spoilers here...) I hung with this book, I read it far too late at night when I should have been sleeping. I wanted so much to like it.

I felt like the book had quite a lot of potential but towards the last 1/8th of the book it just lost all momentum with a strange ending. The wrap-up just left me feeling like I'd wasted all those hours reading and sticking with it.

The characters had so much potential, I'm a huge "dog book" fan and wanted so much for everything to be explained and developed. Yet readers are left with too many loose, strange ends -- what was with Ida, why not develop the characters more? It felt like the author either ran up against a deadline and had to finish things quickly, or he just didn't know what to do with all of the characters at the end of the book.

For a dog-based novel that will make you cry, laugh, and examine life, I would recommend looking elsewhere such as, "The Art of Racing in the Rain". In the end, I just ended up feeling like I'd wasted my time on this book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-23 11:06:51 EST)
09-21-08 3 0\1
(Hide Review...)  Litter
Reviewer Permalink
Beautifully written, but as with many fine authors, they fall in love with their "Voice" Too much of a good thing.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-23 11:06:51 EST)
09-21-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Oprah's Next Book Club Pick!
Reviewer Permalink
Everything Oprah touches turns to gold, and this debut novel by David Wroblewski was golden the minute his words hit the pages. A simple story about a mute boy and his dog, turns complex by a complicated modern world, will have you turning the pages quickly. A modern day HAMLET, Shakespeare himself would be proud.
It's time for Oprah to select a teen novel for her next book club pick, to get young adults excited about reading. I recommend Kane's CONFESSIONS OF A CATHOLIC SCHOOLGIRL, not just because it deals with issues teens need to learn about, but because the author donates 25% of proceeds to domestic violence shelters. Oprah would be bringing awareness and help to a neglected cause.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-23 11:06:51 EST)
09-21-08 5 4\4
(Hide Review...)  Not for everyone, but great!
Reviewer Permalink
People are buzzing about this unusual pick from Oprah's book club. Unlike previous choices like The Road Edgar Sawtelle isn't just the story you see in the book. The whole story is a rendition of Hamlet taking place on a rural farm. All of the characters in the book (even the dogs) correspond to characters in Hamlet. It isn't an easy read, but it is a very clever one.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-23 11:06:51 EST)
09-21-08 5 2\3
(Hide Review...)  A thoughtful literary masterpiece!
Reviewer Permalink
The Story of Edgar Sawtelle: A Novel is a thoughtful literary masterpiece. This is not your fast-paced thriller beach read; this is a novel you want to read carefully and allow to steep and absorb.

The characters are complexly drawn, three-dimensional and the story itself is highly emotional and inspiring. Edgar, the main protagonist is mute, yet his communication with his dog shows the astounding depths of the relationship between man and animal, and that language is much more than spoken words we hear.

The story had a strong emotional impact on me. Having recently lost my faithful dog of 13 years and later adding a new puppy to our household, it sure made me look at dogs differently. Although the story is fiction and the breed is fictional...well, who knows? Anything is possible, right?

I will admit the story is slow in parts, mainly because I think the author is striving to really paint a picture of the world he's created and the people who live in it. To me, the book's overall plot is a success and the reward for sticking through it all is satisfying. It's the kind of novel I personally prefer. One that makes me think while I'm reading it, and one that I think of long after I've put it down.

I don't expect it will be long before we see this novel made into a movie.

This novel was an honor to read.

~Cheryl Kaye Tardif, bestselling author of Whale Song: A Novel
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-23 11:06:51 EST)
09-20-08 1 2\7
(Hide Review...)  Pointless
Reviewer Permalink
This is a story with a lot of potential. It could have delivered several important messages. In the end it's almost like the author just got tired, abandoned any idea of delivering a message and killed everybody off..the good and the bad. Maybe there is some literary significance to the story...but not for me.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-23 06:05:28 EST)
09-19-08 3 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Hello: It's Hamlet!
Reviewer Permalink
I'm kind of surprised the book review blurbs don't mention that this is Wroblewski's retelling of Hamlet, down to the boy named after his mother, mother Gertrude (Trudy, here), uncle Claudius (Claude) -- not to mention the main character's doubt of his own sanity and procrastination.

Another reviewer mentioned Jane Smiley -- she's also done a Shakespeare spin, with A Thousand Acres (her take on King Lear).

I do think in some ways it helps to know this, as it enhances your reading and enjoyment of the plot. Doesn't spoil it :)
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-21 01:15:55 EST)
09-19-08 2 1\4
(Hide Review...)  Didn't Love the Book
Reviewer Permalink
This was a most disappointing read. I thought there were many threads that went nowhere and the ending was awful. I would not recommend this book to anyone. In fact, I would say, "Don't read it."
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-21 01:15:55 EST)
09-19-08 5 2\2
(Hide Review...)  SOMETHING IS ROTTEN IN THE KINGDOM OF RURAL WISCONSIN.
Reviewer Permalink
David Wroblewski's debut novel is one that stays with you for a very long time. Built around a classic Hamletian scaffolding, it quickly acquires its own original character of a classic novel.

A mute boy, Edgar, is coming of age in a family that raises a special breed of highly intelligent dogs. The strained yet strangely idyllic balance between the uncommunicative boy and the overly communicative dogs soon shatters. Tragedy interlaced with mysteries come rushing in as the father dies and an uncle steps in his place.
When the father's apparitions seem to bring up murder and its investigation precipitates even more tragedy, Edgar runs away in the companion of his dogs...but I digress: I would not want to spoil it for anyone.

Beautiful prose, insightful descriptions of both human and canine emotions and a grasping story make this novel one that you too will greatly enjoy! As a bonus, if you already share your life with a dog, you will appreciate it more; if not, prepare to experience an intense urge to adopt one.

RECOMMENDED!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-21 01:15:55 EST)
09-19-08 3 1\7
(Hide Review...)  I wanted to like it. I really tried!
Reviewer Permalink
I really did want to try it. I usually tear through books quickly if I find it interesting enough, but this book took me forever to read. I personally don't like dogs much (maybe I should have noticed that before ordering it, ha), so the exhaustive descriptions about taking care of dogs bored the heck out of me. I found myself skimming pages to see if there would be anything interesting on that page. I eventually finished the book, but MAN, it bored me to death!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-21 01:15:55 EST)
09-18-08 5 2\3
(Hide Review...)  Superb first novel
Reviewer Permalink
I lugged this heavy book around for a couple of weeks in my back pack, unable and unwilling to put it down. I found the story haunting (no pun intended), very moving, and certainly a heart-breaker. Somehow when we read books we expect everything to sort itself out at the end with a happy ending. Almondine stole my heart, as did Edgar Sawtelle himself. Bravos and kudos to David Wroblewski on his first novel!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-20 12:16:51 EST)
09-18-08 2 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Beautiful enviornment but lacks vision in the plot
Reviewer Permalink
PROS: Beautiful landscape. The connection between human and dogs is rich and touching. Aspects of the story written from the dog's perspective are insightful.

CONS: I was romanced by the set up (the setting of the stage, the development of the characters, the tension of the building conflict) but then the author says "hey! Guess what? This is a retelling of Hamlet!"

WHAT!?? I dont want to read Hamlet! I want an original plot to be told on this wonderful stage. Now that I know that the narrative arc is based on Hamlet, every turn and twist is now forecasted. I can see it all coming...

How utterly disappointing.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-18 15:20:33 EST)
09-18-08 2 2\4
(Hide Review...)  Beautiful enviornment but lacks vision in the plot
Reviewer Permalink
PROS: Beautiful landscape. The connection between human and dogs is rich and touching. Aspects of the story written from the dog's perspective are insightful.

CONS: I was romanced by the set up (the setting of the stage, the development of the characters, the tension of the building conflict) but then the author says "hey! Guess what? This is a retelling of Hamlet!"

WHAT!?? I dont want to read Hamlet! I want an original plot to be told on this wonderful stage. Now that I know that the narrative arc is based on Hamlet, every turn and twist is now forecasted. I can see it all coming...

How utterly disappointing.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-20 12:16:51 EST)
09-17-08 3 1\3
(Hide Review...)  a long read and a disappointing end
Reviewer Permalink
I enjoyed this long book, until the last 150 pages. I thought the author created great characters. But as the book progresses, the reader does not understand the main characters wholly. We are left with no understanding of the antagonist's motivation. It was very contrived and unbelievable. This was so surprising, since the majority of the book was so well written. It is as if the author got tired and wrote a quick ending. I am surprised this book got such great reviews.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-19 02:05:25 EST)
09-17-08 4 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Tragedy
Reviewer Permalink
There is much to like about THE STORY OF EDGAR SAWTELLE. It's different for one thing. The story is built loosely around Shakespeare's HAMLET. Edgar's uncle murders his father and tries to take over the Sawtelle dog kennel business.

The story has two parts. Wroblewski sets up the Hamlet parody early on, but we don't get to see Edgar's father's ghost until a couple of hundred pages in. Meanwhile, Edgar is boiling, trying to muster up the courage to get revenge. When he finally does muster up the courage to try, there's a terrible accident, the family vet winds up dead and Edgar escapes into the Chequamegon National Forest with three of the kennel dogs. The story then becomes a survival narrative of sorts. Edgar has to find a way to feed the animals as well as himself. He breaks into cabins; he steals a fishing rod. After a while, it seems as if he's been living in the woods forever. Wroblewski almost forgets about the Hamlet theme. Edgar raids a house owned by Henry Lamb who takes Edgar and the dogs in when one of the dogs hurts his foot. Henry is a sympathetic character who gives an element of dignity to the human characters in the book who don't always deserved the respect of the dogs.

We also learn quite a bit about dogs and how a dog kennel works. Wroblewski devotes pages to training methods and shows how each dog has its own unique personality. We even get the dog's point of view in several instances, mainly from Almondine, Edgar's best friend, whose reason for living was to protect Edgar. I did have a bit of a problem picturing these dogs. They're not exactly German shepherds, but they seem bigger and were chosen by Edgar's father and grandfather more for their personalities than their physical assets. There's also a great scene where Edgar learns of Almondine's death that really touched me.

No tragedy is worth its salt without a good villain and we've got one here with Claude, Gar's brother. We get to listen to his point of view, but he never really explains himself. We're left to make inferences about why he murdered his brother. He remains an enigma to the end. Pay close attention to the first scene, if you don't want to go back and read it again later.

One way to judge a Hamlet parody is to look at the mystical sequences. I wasn't all that impressed with the scene where Edgar's father appears in the rain. There wasn't enough suspension of disbelief, but I did like the ghost in Henry Lamb's garage later in the story. He's an old farmer who can't bear to leave his wife's things, which are crammed into the old garage. There's also a feral dog in the story, whom Edgar tries to lure into the kennel environment. Edgar's father, Gar, had a dog by the same name, Forte. Forte has some kind of symbolic significance which I was never able to fully pin down. Maybe something about domestication of animals diminishing them in some respect. Edgar also finds a series of letters between his grandfather, John, and an expert on purebred breeding. Apparently his grandfather had tracked down the perfect sire, a dog named Hachiko. Wroblewski never does clarify the importance of Hachiko in the Sawtelle blood line, or if he did, I missed it.

There are some drawbacks to the book, number one being excessive description that doesn't really move the story. I had to read over some of these sentences several times and never was able to untangle some of them. The ending is also confusing. Apparently Wroblewski left some earlier signposts that I also missed, but it does get you thinking and that's a good ending in some circles. Some might be upset by the unhappy ending, but you should remember that the ending to the original wasn't all that happy either. Hamlet was a tragedy, after all, and author David Wroblewski wasn't afraid to write a tragic ending.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-19 02:05:25 EST)
09-17-08 5 0\3
(Hide Review...)  Awesome Debut Novel! Can't Wait for his next Book!
Reviewer Permalink
"The mute hero suffers a tumultuous relationship with his uncle and when his father dies, must observe as the uncle woos our hero's mother. The saving grace in his life and his route to manhood are the three dogs who accompany him on his journey. The dogs are far more likeable than many of the humans in this story as Wroblewski writes with beauty and mystery in this inspired debut novel."
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-19 02:05:25 EST)
09-16-08 2 1\3
(Hide Review...)  Way too wordy
Reviewer Permalink
I read this book because it was so well reviewed. It was slow-starting (after the teaser intro), but I kept at it and, on a few occasions, I was drawn into some twists in the story and a few passages that were nicely written. Throughout the whole book, however, I felt that it could have been edited down to about 50% of its pages. The ending was not satisfying. I read voraciously, so I am familiar with a variety of writing styles. I am sorry I wasted my time on this book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-18 15:20:33 EST)
09-16-08 1 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Hamlet lovers unite!
Reviewer Permalink
The Story of Edgar Sawtelle I love stories set in the Midwest; I love stories about dogs. I don't love rehashed Hamlet tales where evil conquers good. This story drags on for 500-some pages just to leave you flat at the end. I had no problem setting this book down at night before going to bed. There is nothing here to celebrate life in this book. The characters are never allowed to develop into personalites nor do they ever get to have closure to any of the events - they just sort of wander in and wander out until the next chapter where the author introduces some new bizarre piece. The end builds up a bit of steam (not much) only to fizzle out like a balloon losing all it's air or possibly the author really didnt know what to do with his characters. I won't bother spending money on another book by this author - if you're curious - then go to the library and borrow it.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-18 15:20:33 EST)
09-16-08 4 1\1
(Hide Review...)  The Story of Edgar Sawtelle
Reviewer Permalink
Wonderfully written for the first half of the book. Then it got rather slow until the end. The end went so fast that I had to reread it to fully understand what had happened.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-18 15:20:33 EST)
09-15-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Good enough
Reviewer Permalink
Well written and a page-turner...but the end left something to be desired. I guess I don't know enough about Hamlet to appreciate it...but still good enough.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-17 19:30:00 EST)
09-15-08 5 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Living the story
Reviewer Permalink
This novel was so well written that I felt I was living with Edward and feeling his love for dogs and the challenges within his family. The plot unfolded beautifully with surprises around every corner and even till the ending. As raw and real as life can be raising and training hybrid canines in rural Wisconsin. Sure it was slow in parts but worth the anticipation. Well done. Highly recommended. Made me want to own a Sawtelle dog who could teach me something.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-17 19:30:00 EST)
09-15-08 1 4\6
(Hide Review...)  Don't waste your time
Reviewer Permalink
Well, I hung in there reading this book, even though it got a little tedious at times. Mainly because I wanted to see what would happen in the end. I was so disappointed in the ending that now I wish I never read the book at all. I feel kind of like I wasted a lot of time reading to get to an ending that left me feeling empty. There are many other books out there to read that leave you feeling more satisfied. I would not recommend this book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-17 19:30:00 EST)
09-14-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Reluctantly finished a book I didn't want to end
Reviewer Permalink
The reviews were glowing, and, honestly, that's what prompted me to purchase the book, along with another highly recommended book. I can't explain why I picked up this one first, other than that Stephen King's review grabbed my attention. AND, Was he ever so right! ! ! I've had amazing dogs that I have trained and enjoyed the company of for many years. I was so completely absorbed in the story of Edgar Sawtelle, that when my husband suddenly coughed at page 500 or so, I almost leapt out of my skin. Never before have I been so transfixed by fiction, with the possible exception of The Stand, by said Stephen King. I highly recommend this book to all, and particularly to those who have enjoyed the companionship of dogs, as well as other similarly important "people".
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-17 01:15:27 EST)
09-13-08 5 2\3
(Hide Review...)  The Story of Edgar Sawtelle - Novel by David Wroblewski
Reviewer Permalink
I would highly recommend this book. One of the Best Books I have read this year.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-13-08 5 1\1
(Hide Review...)  I LOVED THIS BOOK
Reviewer Permalink
I buy very little fiction, especially in hardback, but was prompted to buy this book because of the glowing reviews marking it as a lovely, slow summer book....... and that it is! I did try to read it slowly so I could savor the writing and the many delicious details about the characters and the places, and that is the way to read it! At first I thought I could not read a book about a boy and a dog without sobbing all the way through it, and a mute boy, no less! But I did read it, and I only sobbed in a couple of places, mostly because of the sweetness of Almondine. I was shocked at the end, but it all made sense when I got a little perspective on it, especially after reading parts of Hamlet. I read that "Hamlet is a tragedy about a man who couldn'tmake up his mind" and that theme does not pertain to Edgar Sawtelle, but other themes of the play do, and that makes this book even more intricate and thrilling.

All through the pages of this book I had a picture in my mind's eye of what was being described, and was hoping that there will be a movie of the book.... but ONLY if it is done with respect, and WITHOUT any known Hollywood-types so we can keep some of the mystery and real-ness of the book.

I read that the author grew up with dogs and longed for a book about a boy and his dog... .and he mentioned Jack London's The Call of the Wild, so I picked that up right after finishing Edgar Sawtelle. It is very different, but so well written and so descriptive, and very exciting, etc..... so I am glad for the referral.

There is a lot of discussion about Edgar Sawtelle on these pages at Amazon, and I am anxious to read some of them. I skimmed them, and noticed lots of different interpretations and opinions.... and I also am very pleased to see the book remain on best seller lists across the country! There is hope for us yet!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-13-08 4 2\3
(Hide Review...)  BUT FOR THE ENDING ~~~~
Reviewer Permalink
Everything written already lauding the beauty of the setting and prose I must agree with. I will add the wonderful tension and pacing to the mix of perfect elements. The POV changes were painless. Given the story of the dogs' breeding made it acceptable (after the first time) when we heard the dogs' thoughts. The limited cast of characters, the small geographical area, the consistency of everything were all together and individually near perfect.

HOWEVER -- the ending .. the ending. Until the last 30 pages, I would have stood it against anything written -- British, Russian, French, German or American -- for the past hundred and fifty years.

The writing continued its perfect quality; the mood and tension were sustained from start to finish. But the way the ending unfolded was unfair.

Unfair to the reader and equally to the writer. The ending didn't have to change; it just should have been finessed and transitioned more effectively. From the time that Glen got hold of Edgar, the plot sped out of control. I'd rather have seen this as a two-book set than in this format, which feels abbreviated.

Unfair: Edgar never proved (to himself or his mother) what Claude had done.

Unfair: The power of Almondine's love did not "save" Edgar and it should have. I get the whole "choice" thing. I get the metaphor of the dog breeding symbolizing the wacky ideas of controlling the fate of the human race and that Edgar would by some people be thought of as not good stock. But Almondine's presence gave Edgar a "voice." She should have saved him and that doesn't mean keeping him alive for a sequel. She could have given Edgar back to his mother for even a moment, so that she could know the purpose of his sacrifice.

Uunfair: Essay never got to mate with Forte. I don't recall reading anything about neutering/spaying in the kennel, and we know many of the females had come into heat over the course of the book. Essay should have been pregnant by the time they got home. The set up of her wanderings with Forte, the description of her "mood" when she returned from being with Forte all suggested as much.

Unfair: Glen being "blinded" literally and figuratively because of Claude, and being forced to living up to the ox references.

Unfair: Since it was so important to Edgar it became important to me: Why didn't we ever get to know how Gar and Trudy met?

I agree with another poster here that it seemed to be a matter of time/length. Couldn't the author have cut out some of the details concerning the difficulties immediately after Gar's death and Claude's sinister takeover? (The pneumonia scenes were quite extensive). Some of Henry's sections could have been shaved -- I think we figured it out early on that Edgar "saved" Henry -- all those pages could have been devoted to Edgar.

But really, I loved it. Fabulous, worth the money and time I gave to it. Highly recommended. If Mr. W. would rewrite it from the return trip home, after leaving the dogs with Henry, I'd buy it again and start from the beginning. There are too many other not so important details left untended. Ida Paine. Which rat did Claude initially need the potion for; is that why he'd been in prison? What was Schultz' reason for running away from the farm?

Do you see how wonderful the book is? Feel how deeply it gets inside? All those questions were made important and not attended to. I choose to blame the publisher.

Write On, Mr. W... looking forward to more from you.

(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-12-08 3 3\4
(Hide Review...)  Good Not Great
Reviewer Permalink
There are a zillion reviews here but I'll chip in my two cents none the less. I read the book based on the hype and thought the content around dog training was the most interesting element. Otherwise I thought it a bit "soft" overall and at times the plot advanced dreadfully slow for a 500 plus page novel.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-12-08 5 2\3
(Hide Review...)  Awesome
Reviewer Permalink
Beautifully written, this book is unique in so many ways. I was enthralled and am very much impressed. It is not like any other book I have ever read.
I highly recommend it.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-12-08 5 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Excellent book.
Reviewer Permalink
With the exception of a strange visit to a chemist who demonstrates a poison by killing a stray dog, the beginning of this novel is so like finding home that I almost stopped reading because I dreaded what would come next. That visit kept this world from becoming too comfortable, and foretold hard times. Like getting out of the water, the second half of the book is uncomfortable, if necessary. This is a great first novel, compelling and enthralling.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-12-08 3 2\2
(Hide Review...)  An engrossing narrative marred by a weak ending
Reviewer Permalink
"The Story of Edgar Sawtelle" is a debut novel by an interesting new author and for the most part, I truly did enjoy the book. The story of a mute boy,his relationship with his family and especially his close affinity to the dogs the family breeds really pulled me into a unique world. There are many themes within this story, i.e. family dynamics, the relationship between man and animal [dogs], the supernatural, revenge etc.

The young, mute Edgar Sawtelle goes through quite a lot in this novel and it is his close relationship with man's best friend that made this an interesting read for me. Yet what seemed a remarkable piece of storytelling seemed to collapse towards the end of the novel with what I felt was such a waste of a truly interesting and unique protagonist. For this reason I could only give the book three stars. It is a good read nevertheless and I still hope to read more from this author [who will perhaps have better editors in the future].
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-15 03:27:02 EST)
09-11-08 3 2\3
(Hide Review...)  How an editor runed a fabulous story
Reviewer Permalink
The is a marvelously well told story, full of detail about special boy, his family, a developing breed of dogs, with some ghosts thrown in, and the ultimate crime, murder. It reads easily, all that is until the last few pages. What in world took over the author to absolutely ruin an great story with sequel possibilites, must have been the editor who said, 'OK, now its too long, just end by killing off the main character' Ridiculous- and the first time author must have agreed. BIG mistake.
The ending is just a rude way to treat those of us who followed this story all the way. Why ruin this superb tale, as at least 99.9% of it was, with a quick asinine ending that didn't just didn't have to be. Disgusting! and I am furious that it was allowed to happen. Wasted reading.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-13 02:28:31 EST)
09-10-08 2 1\3
(Hide Review...)  Nice doggie.
Reviewer Permalink
Original premise. Interesting facts about dog training. But in the end your left with unaswered questions.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-13 02:28:31 EST)
09-10-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Prose that heels
Reviewer Permalink
The Stern Librarian likes unruly dogs, who jump on the furniture and have a will of their own. I like prose that is similarly uninhibited. In this book of a lot of dogs and a lot of words, I found neither. I wanted to release stays on both. If the author has something of value of say about whether dogs can be bred for empathy and intelligence (there is, for example, a side trip to Japan to meet the famous dog who went to the train station every day to welcome his master home for many years after the master had died), I lost that thread somewhere in the 600 pages of the novel. Although the relationship between Almondine and Edgar is affecting, the book loses its drive once Edgar and his mother are left on their own. Curiously it is the scenes we don't get in Hamlet--the idyll before the king dies--that display the most energy and imagination. Although it seems permissible for the author to occasionally slip into the dog's point of view, it is never enough for him to tell us how just once how the dogs react and think in a given situation. We get the thoughts of the entire kennel, which does nothing to speed the lugubrious pacing of the middle of the book. Nonetheless, this morning a Patron raved to me about how much she loved this novel, despite being a cat person. For her, I have given this book an additional star. The Stern Librarian (I fetch books).
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-13 02:28:31 EST)
09-10-08 3 2\2
(Hide Review...)  Not Lassie & Timmy
Reviewer Permalink
Intrigued that this is on best seller list. I am true dog lover. Loved all the dogs in this book, and rooted for Edgar to the very end. What a wonderful character!! Can't believe debut author took an inspiring first book and decided the main character was not worthy of a second story. So many questions unanswered. Unlike Dean Koontz character, Odd Thomas who goes on to other marvelous adventures the ending of this lengthy novel brings only grief and the question of WHY?
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-13 02:28:31 EST)
09-10-08 4 2\3
(Hide Review...)  Fabulous book..until the ending
Reviewer Permalink
I read this book in two days...that's right. I couldn't put the book down, yet I didn't want to finish the book either, as it had become my escape from work and day to day chores. I fell in love with the dogs and the mute boy and believed in his devotion and their loyalty to him. Sawtelle takes you on this wonderful and tragic journey and then suddenly ends this 700+ pages book, suddenly and abruptly, as if he ran out of things to say or couldn't pull an appropriate ending to his story. I was bewildered by the ending and very disappointed and dumbfounded.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-13 02:28:31 EST)
09-09-08 5 3\3
(Hide Review...)  A Solid Debut
Reviewer Permalink
Good books draw you in and beckon when you are gone. The moment you set eyes upon the page you have stepped into that world and are surrounded in every way to that place, those people, and in this case those Sawtelle dogs. Mind you, this was not an easy book for me to read. The second half was difficult, and the ending isn't tidy as I almost hoped for, but the writing, the characters, this story makes you endure it in a satisfying way. A fine debut and the kind of book that when I look back upon the title, or see the cover (which aptly portrays it) I will immediately be next to Edgar, his dogs, that farm, that place, in that story.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-13 02:28:32 EST)
09-08-08 3 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  A collection of short stories
Reviewer Permalink
Like so many other readers I was caught up in the hype of the novel. After completing it I came to the conclusion that due to all the back stories some of which don't even seem to relate to the central theme (cleaning out the shed and the appearance of it's original owner) that this book would have been better sold as a collection of short stories. It does drag at times too often and it's easy to get lost and begin to wonder what the author is trying to tell us. As for the accuracy of the dogs and their training I noticed the author seemed to completely neglect any of his animals going into heat and the males reaction to this.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-11 00:45:01 EST)
09-08-08 2 1\5
(Hide Review...)  Ok beginning, great middle, huge let down ending
Reviewer Permalink
I had high hopes for this book after seeing the author in a Today show interview discussing how he went from being a computer programmer to a writer (he mentioned having to go back to school to learn creative writing). It was quite obvious in the first few chapters that he was new to writing, as I found some of the earlier chapters slightly forced. However, the middle was great, although it dragged on a bit to the point where I skimmed a chapter very quickly (the author posed some great questions, and then instead of answering them the book goes on a side-track). This is a long book, so I devoted one weekend to reading it; I just finished the last chapters and the ending was _disappointing_! When you put so much time into reading a long book, you expect a better ending. I felt like the writer just wanted to be dramatic on purpose and create unnecessary complications. I HATE it when writers do this, is this something they teach you in writing school?. Ugh, what a waste of my time. I will not be reading his next book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-11 00:45:01 EST)
09-07-08 5 0\2
(Hide Review...)  Great Story
Reviewer Permalink
This was a book I could not put down.
It keeps you turning the pages.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-10 06:03:56 EST)
09-07-08 4 0\2
(Hide Review...)  Supernatural?
Reviewer Permalink
I purchased the novel to read aloud to my teen/tween-aged grandchildren while on vacation in Minnesota's north woods. The characters were finely drawn and the setting beautifully and accurately described. The parts related to the breeding and training of dogs were simply wonderful. Reading aloud the thoughts of the mute main character didn't work particularly well, but that was expected. The aspect of the book that I really did not like was the mixing of events that actually could have happened with supernatural events that could not have happened. The supernatural aspects are not horrifying but the story depends on receiving messages from ghosts. This appealed to my teenagers but not to adults.

Overall, it was a good read and much enjoyed.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-10 06:03:56 EST)
09-07-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Couldn't Put It Down
Reviewer Permalink
The book is a great page turner. The writing is exceptional and the characters are so well defined - particularly the dogs. It's not a book that will leave you feeling good at the end - or really anywhere in between. I think that's typical of most classics....and this is....a modern tragedy.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-10 06:03:56 EST)
09-07-08 5 0\1
(Hide Review...)  A Sawtelle dog for me!!
Reviewer Permalink
I could not put down this book! The story appealed to me for its uniqueness: the unusual dog breed, its trainers and the training; the different kind of "handicap" for Edgar; the means of communication used by
Edgar and his fascination for words while being unable to speak; the Cain and Able relationship of Gar and
Claude; and the twist on a coming-of-age story. I found it startling yet sensitive, sad but strangely satisfying,
frustrating yet fulfilling, and edgy yet endearing. It was gripping right to the last paragraph.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-10 06:03:56 EST)
09-06-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Review The Story of Edgar Sawtelle
Reviewer Permalink
A debut novel with a haunting impact. Difficult to put down. Beautifully descriptive, tantalizingly frustrating in parts. Not a light fairy floss novel, it will be one of the few novels that I will reread again and I suspect again after that. David Wroblewski will be an author to watch. Highly recommended read.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-09 00:54:40 EST)
09-06-08 5 0\1
(Hide Review...)  Magical storytelling!
Reviewer Permalink
This retelling of Hamlet is intriguing and compelling...and any dog lover will revel in the dogs! Edgar and his family draw you in and keep you there...
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-09 00:54:40 EST)
09-05-08 1 1\4
(Hide Review...)  Life is to short!
Reviewer Permalink
The book was written well and kept me reading it, but in the end I was left wanting a different story altogether. Life is to short to read such a depressing book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-07 06:18:34 EST)
09-04-08 3 1\1
(Hide Review...)  What is all the excitement about?
Reviewer Permalink
I am very conflicted about this work. Obviously, he can write beautifully, and evocatively, of the countryside. This book has a very strong sense of place. Also, his description of the relationship of Edgar and the dogs is moving, and really altered the way I relate to my own dog. However, I had many problems with this book, namely:
1. It is way too long, in the wrong ways. The very long section wherein Edgar runs away from home seemed almost totally unnecessary and did not move the story forward
2. Claude is drawn in a unidimensional way, as a nefarious sociopath. That Trudy, who is such a strong, intelligent and insightful woman, could be drawn to him and not see through him just didn't wash for me.
3. Without revealing too much, it was unnecessarily tragic
4. The book did not break any new ground, nor did it seem particularly insightful. In fact, I liked Old Yeller better.
I just don't get all the excitement about this book...except that it is about dogs, and everybody loves dogs.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-05 01:13:10 EST)
09-04-08 4 1\3
(Hide Review...)  Story telling at its best.
Reviewer Permalink
Excellent story telling technique makes material that is not at first glance the best for a suspenseful page-turner into just that. Vivid descriptions advance, do not distract from, the story.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-05 01:13:10 EST)
09-04-08 1 4\5
(Hide Review...)  What a selfish writer!
Reviewer Permalink
I think that the author is an outstanding writer however, I also think he is mean spirited. The author has us read and fall in love with the characters in this story and then to change the story from one of heartfelt truth about how families and people think and grieve to one in which he shows his true colors as a mean spirited hateful ending. Just shows that just because a person is talented doesn't mean they are kind.
Don't bother to read this book. The author sells it as a American story and then only hurts you in the end. Shame on Steven King (who I love as a writer) for recommending it.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-07 06:18:34 EST)
09-04-08 3 2\2
(Hide Review...)  What is all the excitement about?
Reviewer Permalink
I am very conflicted about this work. Obviously, he can write beautifully, and evocatively, of the countryside. This book has a very strong sense of place. Also, his description of the relationship of Edgar and the dogs is moving, and really altered the way I relate to my own dog. However, I had many problems with this book, namely:
1. It is way too long, in the wrong ways. The very long section wherein Edgar runs away from home seemed almost totally unnecessary and did not move the story forward
2. Claude is drawn in a unidimensional way, as a nefarious sociopath. That Trudy, who is such a strong, intelligent and insightful woman, could be drawn to him and not see through him just didn't wash for me.
3. Without revealing too much, it was unnecessarily tragic
4. The book did not break any new ground, nor did it seem particularly insightful. In fact, I liked Old Yeller better.
I just don't get all the excitement about this book...except that it is about dogs, and everybody loves dogs.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-07 06:18:34 EST)
09-04-08 3 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Sometimes interesting, occasionally drags
Reviewer Permalink


That David Wroblewski can write is plain to any reader of The Story of Edgar Sawtelle, in places his prose literally sing off the page. Likewise, he has done an excellent job of researching his material, particularly as it relates to dogs and breeding, a topic clearly close to his heart. His decision to make Edgar mute also shows a great deal of creativity and serves to deepen the work considerably.

However, the book suffers from several short comings, some of which are not uncommon for first time novelists, others of plot, and still others which might have been handled by a good editor. To begin with the third, at more than 550 pages, the book feels way too long, with a great deal of background information which fails to come to any fruition later in the book. The author's choice to write an homage to Hamlet makes this particularly clear; while no one has ever accused the Bard's longest play of brevity, the Ghost of Act I, scene 4 here appears to young Edgar, around page 230! A good edit could well have slimmed down that first half and tightened this novel. Also, an editor would have pointed out how many of these characters appear two-dimensional; where the characters of Hamlet are among the most complex in the history of literature, here the villain Claude becomes a rather flat uninteresting socio-path. Trudy (Gertrude) becomes the font of the good mother. Only Edgar (and his dog Almondine) show signs of the necessary depth to be consistently interesting.

On another note, Mr. Wroblewski follows the modern vogue, jumping from character to character, even to one of the dogs. While this sometimes serves to improve a work, here it feels often unnecessary and sometimes forced, a way of avoid the work of displaying a character's motivations through actions by instead leaping inside his head.

Where The Story of Edgar Sawtelle offers much to admire, it also leaves the reader wondering how much better it could have been had the many fine authors on the jacket spent less time on effusive blurbs, and more offering the writer notes on how to sharpen his story.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-09-07 06:18:34 EST)
  
                  Reader Reviews 1 - 50 of 347            Next
  
  
  
  
  
  

Because the data used to generate this site come from outside sources, VeryWellSaid.com cannot guarantee the completeness or accuracy of the data.
Search VeryWellSaid™
Google
Web VeryWellSaid™
New subjects are added every week.
View Subjects Below by:
* Top Selling
 (click category name, left)
* Top-Rated Top Sellers
 (click 'Top Rated', right)
In the news...  
Dubai\UAE Top Rated
Influenza\Bird Flu Top Rated
Iraq Top Rated
Supreme Court Top Rated
All Books Top Rated
Arts Top Rated
Photography Top Rated
Digital Photography Top Rated
Digital Cameras Top Rated
Biography Top Rated
Business Top Rated
Management Top Rated
Marketing Top Rated
Sales Top Rated
Stocks Top Rated
Bonds Top Rated
Real Estate Top Rated
Trading Top Rated
Commodities Trading Top Rated
Time Management Top Rated
Starting A Business Top Rated
Children's Top Rated
Comics Top Rated
Computers Top Rated
PC Top Rated
Mac Top Rated
Programming Top Rated
Design Patterns Top Rated
.Net Top Rated
C# Top Rated
Vb.Net Top Rated
Asp.Net Top Rated
Java Top Rated
Python Top Rated
PHP Top Rated
Perl Top Rated
Javascript Top Rated
Ajax Top Rated
CSS Top Rated
Open Source Top Rated
SQL Top Rated
Databases Top Rated
Oracle Top Rated
MySql Top Rated
Sql Server Top Rated
IIS Top Rated
Apache Top Rated
Linux Top Rated
Windows Server Top Rated
Project Management Top Rated
HTML Top Rated
UML Top Rated
IT Certifications Top Rated
Cisco Certifications Top Rated
MCSE Top Rated
MCSD Top Rated
Cooking Top Rated
Italian Cooking Top Rated
Vegetarian Cooking