Aggressive Nationalism: McCulloch v. Maryland and the Foundation of Federal Authority in the Young Republic

  Author:    Richard E. Ellis
  ISBN:    0195323564
  Sales Rank:    541736
  Published:    2007-07-18
  Publisher:    Oxford University Press, USA
  # Pages:    280
  Binding:    Hardcover
  Avg. Rating:    5.0 based on 2 reviews
  Used Offers:    5 from $17.88
  Amazon Price:   
  (Data above last updated:  2008-06-09 07:02:22 EST)
  
  
Sort customer reviews by:
  
Show All Reviews on Page      Hide All Reviews on Page
   
  
Aggressive Nationalism: McCulloch v. Maryland and the Foundation of Federal Authority in the Young Republic
  
McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) has long been recognized to be one of the most significant decisions ever handed down by the United States Supreme Court. Indeed, many scholars have argued it is the greatest opinion handed down by the greatest Chief Justice, in which he declared the act creating the Second Bank of the United States constitutional and Maryland's attempt to tax it unconstitutional. Although it is now recognized as the foundational statement for a strong and active federal government, the immediate impact of the ruling was short-lived and widely criticized. Placing the decision and the public reaction to it in their proper historical context, Richard E. Ellis finds that Maryland, though unopposed to the Bank, helped to bring the case before the Court and a sympathetic Chief Justice, who worked behind the scenes to save the embattled institution. Almost all treatments of the case consider it solely from Marshall's perspective, yet a careful examination reveals other, even more important issues that the Chief Justice chose to ignore. Ellis demonstrates that the points which mattered most to the States were not treated by the Court's decision: the private, profit-making nature of the Second Bank, its right to establish branches wherever it wanted with immunity from state taxation, and the right of the States to tax the Bank simply for revenue purposes. Addressing these issues would have undercut Marshall's nationalist view of the Constitution, and his unwillingness to adequately deal with them produced immediate, widespread, and varied dissatisfaction among the States. Ellis argues that Marshall's "aggressive nationalism" was ultimately counter-productive: his overreaching led to Jackson's democratic rejection of the decision and failed to reconcile states' rights to the effective operation of the institutions of federal governance. Elegantly written, full of new information, and the first in-depth examination of McCulloch v. Maryland, Aggressive Nationalism offers an incisive, fresh interpretation of this familiar decision central to understanding the shifting politics of the early republic as well as the development of federal-state relations, a source of constant division in American politics, past and present.
                  Reader Reviews 1 - 2 of 2                 
  
  
Review
Date
Review
Rating(5 High)
Review
Helpful
to:
Customer Review Reviewer
Info
Permanent
Link
Reader Reviews Below Sorted by Newest First
02-16-08 4 3\4
(Hide Review...)  The Big Case
Reviewer Permalink
For those with an interest in the early history of the U.S. Constitution and the key federal case that largely determined the future power balance between the national government and states.

This book also will be of great value to those desiring a better understanding of the country's first banking system and the economic issues present as our country took wing. Actually, this effort is more about the Second Bank of the United States than the legal proceeding of McCulloch v. Maryland.

Professor Ellis downplays the contemporary importance of this famous case while also, I think, undervaluing the contributions of our greatest Chief Justice, John Marshall.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-06-09 07:05:59 EST)
01-25-08 5 3\3
(Hide Review...)  A New Analysis of one of the Most Important Supreme Court Decisions in American History
Reviewer Permalink
This book is a sophisticated reinterpretation of a critical court case in the early national period. McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) has been one of the two most cited cases of the Marshall Court, enforcing the implied powers of the national government over those of the states. Ellis turns that fundamental result on its head and asks what the immediate repercussions of the decision might have been. He finds that immediately thereafter the ruling was largely ignored, even widely criticized. He also offers a counter to the dominant position about Marshall's nation-building theme, by suggesting that if we move beyond the Chief Justice's nationalistic perspective alternative positions were appropriate but largely ignored by the decision.

The case was really about the constitutionality of the Second Bank of the United States, a public/private partnership that some believed represented a gross overstepping of legitimate federal power. At a fundamental level it represented a debate over national prerogative versus states' rights. Marshall ignored in his opinion many of the points that seemed to be of the most concern to the defendants. Those included the propriety of the federal government chartering a private, profit-making national bank, that bank's authority to conduct its business wherever it wished, its imperviousness to taxation and regulation, and a host of other concerns. Looked at in this manner, the state of Maryland had an important matter for resolution that Marshall decided not to address.

Instead John Marshall reemphasized the power of the federal government to the exclusion of the rights of the states. This important contention would consume national/state relations through the Civil War era and some might say that it is still far from settled. "Aggressive Nationalism" is a good title for this book as Marshall defended that to the exclusion of any sense of state prerogative.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-02-16 19:17:16 EST)
  
                  Reader Reviews 1 - 2 of 2                 
  
  
  
  
  
  

Because the data used to generate this site come from outside sources, VeryWellSaid.com cannot guarantee the completeness or accuracy of the data.
Search VeryWellSaid™
Google
Web VeryWellSaid™
New subjects are added every week.
View Subjects Below by:
* Top Selling
 (click category name, left)
* Top-Rated Top Sellers
 (click 'Top Rated', right)
In the news...  
Dubai\UAE Top Rated
Influenza\Bird Flu Top Rated
Iraq Top Rated
Supreme Court Top Rated
All Books Top Rated
Arts Top Rated
Photography Top Rated
Digital Photography Top Rated
Digital Cameras Top Rated
Biography Top Rated
Business Top Rated
Management Top Rated
Marketing Top Rated
Sales Top Rated
Stocks Top Rated
Bonds Top Rated
Real Estate Top Rated
Trading Top Rated
Commodities Trading Top Rated
Time Management Top Rated
Starting A Business Top Rated
Children's Top Rated
Comics Top Rated
Computers Top Rated
PC Top Rated
Mac Top Rated
Programming Top Rated
Design Patterns Top Rated
.Net Top Rated
C# Top Rated
Vb.Net Top Rated
Asp.Net Top Rated
Java Top Rated
Python Top Rated
PHP Top Rated
Perl Top Rated
Javascript Top Rated
Ajax Top Rated
CSS Top Rated
Open Source Top Rated
SQL Top Rated
Databases Top Rated
Oracle Top Rated
MySql Top Rated
Sql Server Top Rated
IIS Top Rated
Apache Top Rated
Linux Top Rated
Windows Server Top Rated
Project Management Top Rated
HTML Top Rated
UML Top Rated
IT Certifications Top Rated
Cisco Certifications Top Rated
MCSE Top Rated
MCSD Top Rated
Cooking Top Rated
Italian Cooking Top Rated
Vegetarian Cooking Top Rated
Wine Top Rated
Engineering Top Rated
Entertainment Top Rated
Health Top Rated
Nutrition Top Rated
Dieting Top Rated
Sex Top Rated
History Top Rated
Military History Top Rated
British History Top Rated
Middle East History Top Rated
Land Battles Top Rated
Naval Warfare Top Rated
Air Warfare Top Rated
9/11 Top Rated
Terrorism Top Rated
Home Top Rated
Mortgage\Home Equity Loan Top Rated
Cars Top Rated
Car Buying Top Rated
Sports Cars Top Rated
Cat Top Rated
Humor Top Rated
Horror Top Rated
Law Top Rated
IP Law Top Rated
Legal History Top Rated
Fiction Top Rated
Oprah's Book Club Top Rated
Medicine Top Rated
Cancer Top Rated
Stroke Top Rated
Heart Disease Top Rated
Fertility Top Rated
Diabetes Top Rated
Pharmacology Top Rated
Back Problems Top Rated
Menopause Top Rated
Thyroid Top Rated
Pain Top Rated
Organic Chemistry Top Rated
Immune System Top Rated
Mystery Top Rated
Nonfiction Top Rated
Outdoors Top Rated
Running Top Rated
Radio Control Models Top Rated
Guns Top Rated
Parenting Top Rated
Divorce Top Rated
Professional Top Rated
Reference Top Rated
Religion Top Rated
Romance Top Rated
Science Top Rated
Physics Top Rated
Chemistry Top Rated
Astronomy Top Rated
Psychology Top Rated
Science Fiction Top Rated
Sports Top Rated
Teens Top Rated
Travel Top Rated
USA Top Rated
Europe Top Rated
France Top Rated
Italy Top Rated
England Top Rated
China Top Rated
All Books Arts Biography Click Here For An A-Z Index Of All 213 Best-Seller Subjects Business Children's Comics
Computers Cooking Engineering Entertainment Health History Home Horror Humor Law Fiction Medicine Mystery
Nonfiction Outdoors Parenting Professional Reference Religion Romance Science Sci-Fi Sports Teens Travel
In Association with Amazon.com

Cache miss
(not cached)