A Lion Among Men: Volume Three in the Wicked Years (The Wicked Years)

  Author:    Gregory Maguire
  ISBN:    0060548924
  Sales Rank:    117
  Published:    2008-10-01
  Publisher:    William Morrow
  # Pages:    336
  Binding:    Hardcover
  Avg. Rating:    4.0 based on 27 reviews
  Used Offers:    31 from $13.60
  Amazon Price:    $17.79
  (Data above last updated:  2008-11-29 01:28:18 EST)
  
  
Sort customer reviews by:
  
Show All Reviews on Page      Hide All Reviews on Page
   
  
A Lion Among Men: Volume Three in the Wicked Years (The Wicked Years)
  

"Hardly more than a kitten . . . I had thought to call it Prrr, but it shivers more often than it purrs, so I call it Brrr instead."
—From Wicked

Since Wicked was first published in 1995, millions of readers have discovered Gregory Maguire's fantastically encyclopedic Oz, a world filled with characters both familiar and new, darkly conceived and daringly reimagined. In the much-anticipated third volume of the Wicked Years, we return to Oz, seen now through the eyes of the Cowardly Lion—the once tiny cub defended by Elphaba in Wicked.

While civil war looms in Oz, a tetchy oracle named Yackle prepares for death. Before her final hour, an enigmatic figure known as Brrr—the Cowardly Lion—arrives searching for information about Elphaba Thropp, the Wicked Witch of the West. As payment, Yackle, who hovered on the sidelines of Elphaba's life, demands some answers of her own.

Brrr surrenders his story to the ailing maunt: Abandoned as a cub, his earliest memories are gluey hazes, and his path from infancy in the Great Gillikin Forest is no Yellow Brick Road. Seeking to redress an early mistake, he trudges through a swamp of ghosts, becomes implicated in a massacre of trolls, and falls in love with a forbidding Cat princess. In the wake of laws that oppress talking Animals, he avoids a jail sentence by agreeing to serve as a lackey to the war-mongering Emperor of Oz.

A Lion Among Men chronicles a battle of wits hastened by the Emerald City's approaching armies. What does the Lion know of the whereabouts of the Witch's boy, Liir? What can Yackle reveal about the auguries of the Clock of the Time Dragon? And what of the Grimmerie, the magic book that vanished as quickly as Elphaba? Is destiny ever arbitrary? Can those tarnished by infamy escape their sobriquets—cowardly, wicked, brainless, criminally earnest—to claim their own histories, to live honorably within their own skins before they're skinned alive?

At once a portrait of a would-be survivor and a panoramic glimpse of a world gone shrill with war fever, Gregory Maguire's new novel is written with the sympathy and power that have made his books contemporary classics.

About the Author

Gregory Maguire is the bestselling author of Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister, Lost, Mirror Mirror, and the Wicked Years series, which includes Wicked, Son of a Witch, and A Lion Among Men. Wicked, now a beloved classic, is the basis for the Tony Award-winning Broadway musical of the same name. Maguire has lectured on art, literature, and culture both at home and abroad. He lives with his family near Boston, Massachusetts.

A Letter from Gregory Maguire

Dear friends,

Here it is: volume three in my series coming to be known as The Wicked Years. I have had such warm reader response to Wicked and Son of a Witch, both initially and in the years since, that the thought of adding to the series made me feel--well, cowardly. I resisted for a while. But courage comes to those who wait, sometimes: so here is volume three.

A Lion Among Men follows the peripatetic career of the Cowardly Lion. First seen in Wicked as a lion cub culled from his pride for the purpose of laboratory experimentation, the Lion (known as Brrr) makes his name in that little Matter of Dorothy about which all of Oz is still talking. But one doesn’t necessarily become lion-hearted by going after public approval, by racking up those medals and titles and golden statuettes at award ceremonies.

Tarnished with scandal of every stripe, Brrr is loathed by the Animals who believe he betrayed them in helping Dorothy do in the Witch. He fares no better trying to live as a lion among men. When civil war breaks out in Oz, Brrr is caught in the line of fire as he interviews the mysterious old oracle, Yackle, about the sources of Elphaba’s power. He must choose how much approval he can live without. A bit player all his life, he may yet be the linchpin on which the prosecution of the war rests.

When I travel abroad (and the continuing success of the musical Wicked has brought me to countries where it is now playing), I am sometimes met with bemusement about the origins of the material--a children’s book made famous by a musical film for children!--how can this serve as a proper metaphor for a meditation about predestination and free will, about political opportunism and personal valor?

Maybe, I say, you have to be an American to see that a vaudeville comedian in baggy lion-pajamas, as Burt Lahr seemed to me, has just as much right to inspire a story about the education of a hero as any Siegfried or Lancelot or Joan of Arc.

And if they reply, You have some nerve!I answer Thank you. I hope so.

And I do thank you for your lion-hearted confidence in these wicked novels.

-- Gregory

                  Reader Reviews 1 - 29 of 29                 
  
  
Review
Date
Review
Rating(5 High)
Review
Helpful
to:
Customer Review Reviewer
Info
Permanent
Link
Reader Reviews Below Sorted by Newest First
11-29-08 2 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Virtually unreadable - with no storyline
Reviewer Permalink
This is going to prove to be the backbreaker in this series for maguire. Wicked was wonderful, if offputting for many readers. Son of a Witch helped to alienate even more readers with its convoluted storyline, but at least it had a storyline - something was happening throughout the book.

A Lion Among Men has virtually no storyline -- Brrr the cowardly lion recounting (small) portions of his life, and Yackle, not interesting enough to know much about, tying up a bit of information about the Grimmerie -- itself, not interesting enough to know about.

There are a few answers about the Clock of the Time Dragon here -- although not much -- and the books ending leaves every single question readers have unanswered - and I mean every single one: Where is Lir? Where is Candle? Is Elphaba really dead? Is she coming back? Why is the Tin man such an afterthought in these books?

Clearly, there are going to be more books in the Wicked series -- and readers are probably best advised to just skip this third book in the series and wait for the story to come back in the next book.

My fear is that many Maguire readers are going to stop taking the journey after this one.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:08:57 EST)
11-25-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Wow !
Reviewer Permalink
Gregory Maguire is incapable of writing a bad novel ! The reader is drawn helplessly into the story from the first sentence of this book. A wonderful continuation of the Wicked Years.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 01:16:37 EST)
11-22-08 3 1\1
(Hide Review...)  The Third Best
Reviewer Permalink
I was absolutely astounded by Wicked, Maguire's first book in the series. The way he twisted a familiar story into something new and unique was thrilling. If the story hiccuped in places, the strength of plot and character more than made up for it. This third book in the series suffers from the fact that some of the newness has worn off the idea. We have already accustomed ourself to an Oz that is less than perfect and full of complex characters who are not all bad, not all good. So, here we have the Lion, the main character of the third book. I must say that Maguire has an uncanny ability to write female characters. His male characters lack some of the complexity. Of course, the Lion is male. The reader takes a winding journey through his life, sometimes moving back and forward in time, and ends up in a rather unresolved place. It was an interesting story, but there were some loose ends left loose and some parts that I think were added just to keep the mood strange. I was hoping once again to be wowed by Maguire, but I wasn't. It was a bit disappointing.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 00:31:29 EST)
11-22-08 4 0\1
(Hide Review...)  Not satisfied yet!!
Reviewer Permalink
I hope I don't have to wait another 5 or 10 years to find out what happened to Liir. You're killing me, Mr. Maguire!!!!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 00:31:29 EST)
11-21-08 5 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Lovely book, all around.
Reviewer Permalink
As with Maguire's other books, this was an enjoyable read. The dialogue was witty, the characters sympathetic, and the immensity of his commentary on fate and self-determination was powerful enough to propel the end of the novel into an avenue for the series to continue and bring readers back to the politically-charged world of Oz in the future.

Unfortunately, I chose not to, after some waffling, reread Wicked and Son of a Witch. At this point, I wish I had, if only to fully appreciate the reappearance of certain characters and rehashing of events I only barely remembered from the 2 ½ years in between this release and Book 2 and the even longer span between it and Wicked. I managed to piece together events from memory, but am sure it would have felt much more clinching had I been fresh from one to the other. In any event, I recommend this one, even to people who didn't like Son of a Witch. Brrr's early days and burgeoning intellectual abilities are handled rather well. He stumbles with language and concepts such as friendship, morality, and death in such an endearing way, I couldn't help but feel my heart go out to the cynical and bitter Brrr of the present.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 00:31:29 EST)
11-20-08 3 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Has its Shortcomings, but Some Answers are Provided
Reviewer Permalink
I'm assuming that Gregory Maguire will continue writing Wicked books as long as they remain profitable, but I felt "Lion" fell short of his previous successes. While he develops an interesting background for the Cowardly Lion, some of his history seemed irrelevant to the overall plot and I never felt very sympathetic towards him. Sure, it clearly defines how he earned his moniker, but there didn't seem to be much dimension to his character. The interviews with Yackle were interesting enough, revealing a life steeped in mystery. There are a few familiar characters who reenter the scene and add depth to the story. Thankfully, the conclusion offers some answers and some relief that Maguire finally revealed some pertinent information on the overall plot of his (so far) three-book narrative.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-23 00:14:43 EST)
11-19-08 2 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Slow reading and not up to expectations
Reviewer Permalink
I found that it was hard to concentrate on this book. The story line bounced around too much in time and between characters. The lion's back story too long to unfold and was not that interesting. In the previous books the story line was interesting enough to pull me through when the language and geography of the land of Oz would seem confusing but in this one I found I didn't care to even try to figure things out.

The only positive for me was the ending. The ending definitely left a place for another book to start off, I just hope if he writes that book it is more in the nature of the first two. This book to me was just a long entailed way to get to the short end.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-23 00:14:43 EST)
11-17-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  A lion among men
Reviewer Permalink
This book was a great by and a great part in the wicked series I was so excited to get it.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-19 11:15:14 EST)
11-17-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  A Lion Among Men
Reviewer Permalink
So happy to receive the next stroy from the great and wonderful Mr. Gregory Maguire. Thanks for the speedy service.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-19 11:15:14 EST)
11-17-08 1 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  amonther waste of a good title
Reviewer Permalink
I only kind of liked the first book, was out and out dissatisfied/ disgusted with #2 and this on was a waste. I couldn't finish it; better things to do with my time. I'm not even sure the author knows what he's writing about. What's next for this lack luster writer, a perverse re-telling of CS Lewis?
Perhaps if he had created his own world I wouldn't be so put out, but to take a great work of fantasy and social commentary and to twist it like this. DON'T bother reading this.

Stick to re-tellings like those by Robin McKinley or Donna Jo Napoli.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-19 11:15:14 EST)
11-17-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Loved it ... and need more!
Reviewer Permalink
I found I couldn't put this book down until I reached the end. And, while a few questions were answered, it still just skimmed the surface of my curosity. So I sincerely hope Mr. Maguire is working on a 4th book. We need all of the characters between the covers!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-19 11:15:14 EST)
11-16-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Enjoyable book!
Reviewer Permalink
Gregory Maguire did an excellent job of pulling loose ends together and providing answers at the end of this story, while still leaving enough things open that it's conceivable there could be another story to follow. He really develops his characters well, and allows the reader to become acquainted with their thoughts, feelings and motivations. This book was another of his that I didn't want to put down once I started reading, because as with most of his others, the story sucks you in. I would definitely recommend it.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-19 11:15:14 EST)
11-11-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  Best one yet...
Reviewer Permalink
This book is the best one yet. Just as with Elphaba we find that the "Cowardly Lion" is complex and missunderstood. As with all Maguire books it's confusing in spots and painful in others, but, that's what makes his characters so real.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-16 11:25:23 EST)
11-07-08 2 1\2
(Hide Review...)  Revisionist Fantasy
Reviewer Permalink
I am a fan of Maguire's work but did not enjoy this entry in the "Wicked" canon. The Lion is a painfully uninteresting character, less cowardly than laconic in both word and action, who is followed through isolated non-events that unravel very slowly over the course of the book's 300 pages.

Maguire is entering shallow waters with the Oz series. His books after Wicked are not inventive enough for the fantasy genre nor do they have the character development, compelling plot or insight to engage the reader of more serious fare. Maguire disposed of the Witch early on and has abandoned focus on the Wizard and other primary figures. We are left with an exploration of secondary characters such as the lion. As a result, the land of Oz becomes the most compelling feature of the books. Unfortunately, Baum's creation, as revised by MGM and Maguire, has neither the breadth of Middle Earth, the texture of Gormenghast nor the menace of newer fantasy worlds such as those of China Meiville and Jeff Vandermeer.

Maguire's strength is in giving the reader a fresh and contrasting look at alternate worlds that had become overly familiar. I'm not sure there is much else to enliven in the land of Oz. I would much rather see the author present an oblique look at another icon such as Pinnochio or go a different route entirely as was tried, not quite successfully, in Lost.

L. Frank Baum's books came to be redefined for the general public by the MGM movie. Similarly, Maguire's initial novel was reinterpreted by the Broadway musical. He is writing now with reference to both versions. Rather than providing unique revisionist fantasy, Maguire is now constrained by his own inventions. His previous writing was fresh and inventive while his last Oz effort is forced and derivative.

There are better Maguire books to read than A Lion Among Men. As a fan of his work, I am hopeful that this represents his last return to Oz.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-11 12:18:02 EST)
11-06-08 4 1\1
(Hide Review...)  It's no Wicked, but still a great read.
Reviewer Permalink
I'm starting to think that Wicked is a once in a career masterpiece for Gregory Maguire...not that his latest book is bad by any means, it's just not Wicked. I will say it's tons better then the rather disappointing Son of a Witch. In both sequels, the brilliant social, political, and religious commentary that made Wicked so good are sorely missed. There's some, just not as much or as good. Lion Among Men is at least a pretty good story, even if , thinking about it, very little actually happens.
This time in the revisioned land of Oz (a place I'm still very glad I don't live), the story follows the Lion that comes to be known as the Cowardly Lion, Brr. Brr was first seen very briefly in Wicked, having his life saved by as a cub and ultimately having a hand in the death of the witch Elphaba. The matter of Dorothy, as it comes to be known in Oz, only takes up about a chapter, and is almost a footnote in Brr's life. It was complete chance that his life becomes entangled with Elphaba's, which it seems is more significant then it originally seemed. But I'm getting ahead of myself.
Brr is a character that you both simultaneously pity and loathe, in the beginning being naive, oblivious, and a bit thick and then turning bitter and jaded. He has a real talent for continuously being at the wrong place at the wrong time and becomes a victim of both prejudice and bad press. He has several rises and falls from grace in both human and Animal society all across Oz. There's some kind of weird sex along the way that I think I would have been better off not knowing about. Yackle, the dwarf, and the Clock of the Time Dragon are all more or less de-mystified, and I actually think I preferred being in the dark about them. In their explanation though, even more and bigger questions end up being raised. The ending more or less guarantees another book to follow, with a big wrench being thrown into the story at end, and since nothing is followed up from the ending of Son of a Witch and it becomes obvious that Brr's destiny is bound to Liir's (whether that's chance or destiny and a promise to Dorothy finally coming true...well...).
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-11 12:18:02 EST)
11-04-08 3 0\2
(Hide Review...)  Book 3
Reviewer Permalink
Until now, the Cowardly Lion's name has gone unknown; now, thanks to Mr. Maguire, we know him to be Brr. Was he truly a coward, or did he simply not like to fight, preferring more academic pursuits? How did he feel about the Wicked Witch of the West, aka, Elphiba, who helped free him from captivity? In the days following the Wizard's departure, how did he, indeed, how did all of Oz fare and what role did this purported "king of the beasts" play in the shaping of the new order? Was he ever brave enough to fall in love? These questions and more are answered in this chronicle of Oz centered around Brrr, the formerly cowardly Lion, who found his vocation in helping smooth relations between the Animals, not to be confused with mere animals, and Men.

*** Once again, we get a new perspective on the Merry Old Land of Oz, one that is far more political and conflict ridden than the earliest incarnations would have one think, though it is in keeping with the darker versions such as Lost in Oz or Tin Man. Though the reader will be challenged to keep pace of when each scene takes place in the chronology, it is safe to say that if you enjoyed Son of a Witch, you will adore Lion Among Men. ***

Reviewed by Amanda Killgore for Huntress Reviews.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-08 12:03:33 EST)
11-04-08 3 0\2
(Hide Review...)  Decent, but not Great
Reviewer Permalink
Gregory Maguire returns to Oz with this third installment of the Wicked series, A Lion Among Men. This time, Maguire focuses on the story behind Brrr, the Cowardly Lion, and what made him cowardly.

Set after the events of Son of a Witch, A Lion Among Men describes the histories of Brrr and Yackle the oracle. Readers are treated to another wonderful romp through Maguire's vision of Oz, complete with politics and occasional religious undertones. Even though it is not as political as Son of a Witch, Lion weaves another narrative about the beloved creatures that inhabit Maguire's Oz.

Readers follow the history of Brrr from his younger years in the forests through the events that occurred in both Wicked and Son as well as some of the aftermath. Even though it was interesting to hear about previous events through the eyes of a different narrator, I feel like Maguire has overstayed his welcome in Oz. Both this novel and its predecessor constantly discuss events that occurred in Wicked. Even though these events are relevant, it becomes redundant and unsurprising for the reader. I feel like this book doesn't have enough original material to stand on its own as a work separate from its predecessors.

The book also has the tendency to return to questions that were raised in Son about Lir's relationship with Candle, the legitimacy of their daughter, and whether or not his is Elphaba's son.

The character of Yackle the oracle is one purely of Maguire's creation, and it shows. She is a fascinating and unique character, but learning about her seemed to have little purpose in the novel other than to take up space and to infuse it with something new.

However, Maguire's writing talent shines through in this book. Like the other Wicked novels, he forces you to think more when reading and to question your own preconceived notions about people.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-08 12:03:33 EST)
11-03-08 5 0\2
(Hide Review...)  Read it same night it arrived!
Reviewer Permalink
This was a long awaited 3rd book in the Wicked series. This book, without revealing much, tied up a lot of loose ends from the first 2 books. That said, it still left a bit of room for either a 4th book or simply for me to interpret what some of the other characters were up to. I'm hoping there will be more to the series. I enjoyed this book there were some surprises and an interesting point of view from the Lion.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-08 12:03:33 EST)
10-31-08 4 0\1
(Hide Review...)  COWARDLY Lion - No Way!
Reviewer Permalink
A Lion Among Men is the third volume in what Gregory Maguire calls "The Wicked Years." This time the central character is the Cowardly Lion. As was the case with Elphaba, the unfaily maligned Wicked Witch of the West, we learn the Lion is hardly a "coward", rather an unfortuate victim of circumstance that causes his life to shift between success and failure. Old characters are brought back, there are surprises, and I was pleased with this book as much as I was Wicked (the second, Son of a Witch, just didn't cut it. Too many improper plot resolutions). Future suggestions for a book - tell what became of Osma/Tippetarius.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-08 12:03:33 EST)
10-30-08 5 4\5
(Hide Review...)  Maguire continues to amaze with his reinterpretation of classic fairy tales.
Reviewer Permalink
Gregory Maguire is a rare author indeed. He manages to take classic somewhat worn fairy tales and give them a completely new interpretation and perspective that is stunning and thoughtful. And this is his work for adults! I have long been one of his fans, to the point where I have even read a fair number of his books for younger folk to my children. They have loved his originality and genius as well (I think; maybe they just know a good story when they hear one!).

What began for me with "Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister" continued through the first book in the "Wicked" series. I am alternately amazed, bemused, and thrilled by the wonderful plots and beautifully descriptive writing. "Wicked" itself is certainly a masterpiece in my eyes. Not only is it engaging on an almost visceral level, it left me with questions and thoughts for a very long time. It was no surprise to me that it has become practically an icon of pop culture (a Broadway play no less, that of course did not come close to doing this fine work justice). I was not as impressed with "Son of a Witch" which I felt lacked the enduring originality of some of Maguire's other writing. It was nevertheless a great tale in its own right.

"A Lion Among Men" is the latest in this series, and for me it signals a return to Maguire's strongest point as a writer: his ability to create deep empathy for a fictional character by making him as real and lovable/hatable as your next door neighboor. I loved the Cowardly Lion of this tale; his struggles were so utterly human that at times I forgot he was an animal. His search for a place in the human world; his struggle to forget or perhaps understand the past; his attempted sexual conquest; his love for his transparent cat: all of these and so much more made this character one worth getting to know. The Lion's tale was set for the most part amidst great turmoil and political strife in Oz, which was a wonderful counterbalance to the introspection of our protagonist. I was sad when the book ended, for I feel there could be a great deal more to this story. Maybe this character will appear in later books in the series! In short, this was a great, fun and thoughtful read and I cannot wait for Maguire's next book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-08 12:03:33 EST)
10-21-08 5 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Coward No More
Reviewer Permalink

It has been three long years since we last traveled to OZ. And much has changed.

The land, once joined together, is now separated into two parties: those that support the current Wizard of OZ and the Munchkinlanders who long to be free and their own people.

It is not the OZ we've come to know. It is an OZ on the brink of war and on the cusp of social change. Whether it is change for the better remains to be seen.

Heedless of the turmoil of OZ that surrounds him, Brr, The Cowardly Lion, is on a mission. He must find Yackle, Oracle and Seer, and find out why her name was mentioned in the papers of the deceased Miss Morrible. Miss Morrible used to teach Elphaba, The Wicked Witch of the West.

He has other questions too: what really happened to Elphaba? Where is Liir, Elphaba's son? And, though he is loathe to admit it, The Cowardly Lion has questions about himself too. Does Yackle know where he came from? Was he really freed by Elphaba from a cage?

Brr will get the answers he seeks. But first, Yackle wants to know where his life has taken him, what paths have brought him to her. Yackle asks him to tell her of his life before she goes to the life beyond death.

Brr concedes, thinking to tell her a few details to please her so that she will answer his questions. But Brr does not count on the power of the past. Once it is glanced at, it cries out to be examined, to be searched for clues, to be experienced all over again.

Memories, after all, are a powerful magic all their own....

A Lion Among Men is the third book in Maguire's Wicked Years series and it's the best one by far. Where Wicked was good, Son of a Witch was great, A Lion Among Men is amazing!

Wicked suffered from being too long and Son of a Witch suffered from not having enough to do with the characters we know and love from The Wizard of Oz, A Lion Among Men has us once again following the yellow brick road. And boy what a trip.

They say that the third time is a charm and that is certainly the case with Maguire's A Lion Among Men. He's clearly found his stride and it's the best book in the series. What's lovely about the novel is getting to know The Cowardly Lion from a different perspective. We only briefly glimpsed him in Wicked and Son of a Witch.

Now we get to know him intimately. This is his book after all.

And, much like Elphaba who had wickedness thrust upon her, I wonder if Brrr The Cowardly Lion is really cowardly after all.

A Lion Among Men is a very intimate book. As well as getting to know Brrr, we get to know Yackle and how she came to know the two women who would become the Wicked Witches of Oz. Some of the answers we learn in A Lion Among Men were from questions or mysteries first posed in Wicked, so the book should please fans of the series.

But even better than that, A Lion Among men is a wonderful parable and parallel of one lion among men who, though surrounded by people, is incredibly alone.

A Lion Among Men is one portrait of a lonely lion haunted by a need to belong. It's at once funny, charming, harrowing, bleak and incredibly beautiful. If you haven't read A Lion Among Men yet, do yourself a favour and visit OZ again.

We're not in Kansas anymore.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-31 01:12:26 EST)
10-20-08 4 4\4
(Hide Review...)  Read for the characters and Oz
Reviewer Permalink
As I see the Wicked Years (as Maguire has taken to calling this book series), the strongest of the books by a long shot is Wicked. Shadowing the events, places, and characters of the well-known story provided the opportunity for Maguire to provide alternative views of an incredible number of things, not to mention adding details of his own imagining. I termed Wicked astonishing in my review as a result.

With Son of a Witch and A Lion Among Men, I still find Maguire compelling, but these stories aren't quite as rich in the same kind of detail. It was the twist on the familiar that made Wicked *so* well-done. That still happens here to a degree - Maguire is particularly adept at nailing conversational and thought details that accurately reflect the nature of the characters. What's lost, however, is the delicious alternative take on the story you thought you knew. What's left is a very good story to be sure, extending the now familiar Maguire version of Oz, and further developing character versions first introduced in the earlier book(s), but it doesn't quite rise to the same level.

How long can this continue? Got me, though I wouldn't be surprised to see books focused on the Scarecrow and Tin Man in the Wicked Years series. You never know, maybe Maguire will even do an alternative version of the storyline in "Return to Oz" (with Fairuza Balk). If you're going to do alternative takes on fairy tales, you might as well do an alternative on an alternative, too!

A good read, and if you enjoyed Wicked and Son of a Witch, you will also enjoy A Lion Among Men.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-31 01:12:26 EST)
10-19-08 4 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  I was never a fan of the cowardly lion
Reviewer Permalink
So I wasn't sure if I would like this book as much as the other two. But it definitely exceeded my expectations. While the Cowardly Lion isn't all that likeable throughout the book, the book is still readable and enjoyable. This book is told from several viewpoints, and each has its own importance to the tale. The book also takes place over several different time periods. Occasionally I would have to remind myself - is this pre- or post-Dorothy? - but this wasn't really an issue. Overall I found this story to answer so many things that were left hanging, whilst still leaving scope for new questions. As I said before, I never really like the Cowardly Lion before, but now I have a new respect for him as a pivotal character in the tale.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-22 02:03:22 EST)
10-18-08 2 0\1
(Hide Review...)  Not what I had hope for...
Reviewer Permalink
This was not what I had hoped for. Son of a Witch wove a completely different tale that the author did not really address. The first two books were rather consecutive in their timing of events and the third ignored that tale almost entirely. I was hoping for a pick up of the baby that "washed up green"!! This book could almost stand alone...it felt like it was just getting started as it ended. I hope there will be more books....disapointing though.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-21 00:13:15 EST)
10-18-08 5 (NA)
(Hide Review...)  A Great Expansion of Ozian Lore
Reviewer Permalink
A Lion Among Men presents us with a parallel history of events we've witnessed through previous characters' eyes and provides answers to some long standing mysteries. I was thrilled to find the book opened in the mauntery (it seems to bring out the best in Maguire) and the final scene with Yackle has to be read to be believed. A great expansion of Ozian lore, it whets one's appetite for the fourth installment. A side note for those so down on Son of a Witch: reread the opening portion of Part Two, The Service, to help discover the brilliance of that book (and this series in general).
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-21 00:13:15 EST)
10-17-08 4 4\4
(Hide Review...)  Heir to the kingdom
Reviewer Permalink
L. Frank Baum was absolutely fascinated by (and exemplary of) Yankee ingenuity, and that's part of what made Gregory Maguire such a perfect heir to Baum in WICKED, his 1995 dark revisioning of THE WONDERFUL WIZARD OF OZ. One of the greatest pleasures of Maguire's novel was to see how Baum's fantasy world of Oz might look from a more sober adult perspective, and though Maguire's own fantasy of what Oz might be ultimately superseded Baum's (which is appropriate, given that both books are about repeated regime changes), Maguire's dystopic fantasy was aided mightily by the efficient clockwork of Baum's plot acting as a motor propelling the events along. You knew that Elphaba would have to wind up in the Vinkus (or "Winkie Country") as the Wicked Witch of the West, and that Dorothy would come along eventually with that fateful bucket of water. (That Dorothy should show up to be merely a remorseful pawn in the extended games of manipulation waged among Elphaba, the Lady Glinda, and the Wizard was not only Maguire's grandest irony but one of the most satisfying parts of his book.) Maguire's first sequel, SON OF A WITCH, suffered greatly from the removal of this Baumian framework. The masterplot of this later work seemed based on the George W. Bush administration rather than anything dreamed up by L. Frank Baum (with Tip, Mombi, and the four-horned cow making only the briefest of appearances to remind us of Baum's own sequel to his first oz novel). Maguire's vision of sexual couplings hidden against a background of oppression and political upheaval seemed a bit adrift and unfocused, and few of the mysteries raised in Maguire's first book received any answer.

This new sequel, A LION AMONG MEN, finds Maguire on much firmer ground: we're much more firmly rooted in Baum's fantasyland, with the Cowardly Lion (glimpsed only briefly in WICKED) now taking center stage, aided by the Glass Cat, that Baumian character introduced in THE PATCHWORK GIRL OF OZ whose lazy snarkiness made it an absolute natural for inclusion in Maguire's books. Dispatched to interview Yackle, the mysterious old woman who kept appearing at different intervals in Elphaba's life, the Cowardly Lion finds her in the Cloister of St. Glinda not far from the Emerald City, and here we find answers to many of the mysteries from the first book in "The Wicked Years" series: who Yackle is, what happened to Elphaba's Grimmerie, what the inhabitants of the mysterious land of the Glikkus nestled in a far corner of Maguire's Oz are like, and (at last!) what the purpose is of the terrifying Clock of the Time Dragon that haunted the opening sections of WICKED. (We also find out why the Cowardly Lion acquired his adjectival descriptor.) Much is left open, such as the fates of Liir, the true Scarecrow, and (most maddeningly) the missing Ozma, and it's hard to see from how Maguire ends this book as to how the events of THE MAGICAL LAND OF OZ, however distorted, might later come to pass (or even how the Glass Cat will end up eventually at the home of Dr. Pipt). Equally frustrating is the fact that so much of this sequel's action is circumscribed in the Cloister and hemmed in by the Ozian civil wars started since the first book in the series. But even if this work is not quite up to the standards of WICKED, it is certainly quite a great deal stronger and more compelling than SON OF A WITCH.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-21 00:13:15 EST)
10-17-08 4 1\1
(Hide Review...)  Heir to the kingdom
Reviewer Permalink
L. Frank Baum was absolutely fascinated with (and exemplary of) Yankee ingenuity, and that's part of what made Gregory Maguire such a perfect heir to Baum in WICKED, his 1995 dark revisioning of THE WONDERFUL WIZARD OF OZ. One of the greatest pleasures of Maguire's novel was to see how Baum's fantasy world of Oz might look from a more sober adult perspective, and though Maguire's own fantasy of what Oz might be ultimately superceded Baum's (which is appropriate, given that both books are about repeated regime changes), Maguire's dystopic fantasy was aided mightily by the efficient clockwork of Baum's plot acting as a motor propelling the events along: you knew that Elphaba would have to wind up in the Vinkus (or "Winkie Country") as the Wicked Witch of the West, and that Dorothy would come along eventually with that fateful bucket of water: That Dorothy should show up to be merely a remorseful pawn in the extended games of manipulation waged among Elphaba, the lady Glinda, and the Wizard was not only Maguire's grandest irony but one of the most satisfying parts of his book. Maguire's sequel, SON OF A WITCH, suffered greatly from the removal of this Baumian framework. The masterplot of this later work seemed based on the George W. Bush administration rather than anything dreamed up by L. Frank Baum (with Tip, Mombi, and the four-horned cow making only the briefest of appearances to remind us of Baum's own sequel to his first oz novel), and Maguire's vision of sexual couplings hidden against a background of oppression and political upheaval seemed a bit adrift and unfocused, and few of the mysteries raised in Maguire's first book received any answer.

This new sequel, A LION AMONG MEN, finds Maguire on much firmer ground: we're much more firmly rooted in Baum's fantasyland, with the Cowardly Lion (glimpsed only briefly in WICKED) now taking center stage, aided by the Glass Cat, that Baumian character introduced in THE PATCHWORK GIRL OF OZ whose lazy snarkiness made it an aboslute natural for Maguire's vision. Dispatched to interview Yackle, the mysterious old woman who kept appearing at different intervals in Elphaba's life, the Lion finds her in the Cloister of St. Glinda not far from the Emerald City, and here we find answers to many of the mysteries from the first book in "The Wicked Years" series: who Yackle is, what happened to Elphaba's Grimmerie, what the inhabitants of the mysterious land of the Glikkus nestled in a far corner of Maguire's Oz are like, and (at last!) what the purpose is of the terrifying Clock of the Time Dragon that haunted the opening sections of WICKED. (We also find out why the Cowardly Lion acquired his adjectival descriptor.) Much is left open, such as the fates of Liir, the true Scarecrow, and (most maddeningly) the missing Ozma, and its hard to see from how Maguire ends his book how the events of THE MAGICAL LAND OF OZ, however distorted, might come to pass (or even how the Glass Cat will end up eventually at the home of Dr. Pipt). Equally frustrating is the fact that so much of this sequel's action is circumscribed in the Cloister and hemmed in by the civil wars started since the first book in the series. But even if this work is not quite up to the standards of WICKED, it is certainly quite a great deal stronger and more compelling than SON OF A WITCH.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-18 00:24:51 EST)
10-17-08 5 4\4
(Hide Review...)  Loose ends tied up, new doors opened
Reviewer Permalink
One thing that bothered me about "Son of a Witch" was that there was a COMPLETE mystery behind some of the story line, leaving lots of questions from "Wicked" unanswered, as well as creating new questions. I guess thats what makes Maguire's writing so interesting to me.

"A Lion Among Men" answers long awaited questions. The Clock of the Time Dragon? Nor? The Grimmerie? Yackle? All are revealed, but leaves you wondering about the Thropp family line, a great set up for the next installment of the Wicked Years series.

All in all, I enjoyed the book very much, and plan on re-reading "Son of a Witch" to clear my head up a bit about the goings on of the war, etc.

If you liked the first two, chances are you'll really enjoy this one as well. :) Good job GM.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-21 00:13:15 EST)
10-14-08 3 9\12
(Hide Review...)  Relatively Strong with a Few Furry Bits
Reviewer Permalink
Maguire faces a conundrum; he's created arguably one of the most powerful heroines in modern literature and also killed her off as he was required to do; he has to therefore build on the success of Elphaba without being able to portray her. Son of A Witch and now A Lion Among Men continues the story of Oz in which Elphaba acts only as a background character whose presence, because of the success of Wicked, must somehow seep into each subsequent novel.
I did not find Brrr- the Cowardly Lion appealing. I was not as interested in his story as I thought I'd be. I had expected Maguire to weave a traumatic tale of abuse, rejection and how Brrr's relationships in life created a nervous and, perhaps, psychologically disturbed individual. I didn't get that, at least not to the extent I expected from Maguire. Perhaps I just did not engage in Brrr's journey as I found the character quite dislikable and aversive (and not in the Elphaba type of way). I did enjoy the allegorical dimension in which the Lion is perceived as being a collaborationist to the Wizard's regime and also a sympathizer to the Witch's cause at the same time. The discussion regarding the coming and going of different political regimes was also a poignant one. Maguire is a master of political allegory and there is much to be found in this novel. Oz is a rich, dark and complex world on the brink of civil war and Maguire builds the tension brilliantly. With the two Witches who were leaders of separatist states dead, Oz is in freefall.
The novel tells two distinct stories, that of the Lion and that of the mysterious Yackle who appeared to frequent Elphaba's life in Wicked. Although I enjoyed not knowing who Yackle was in Wicked and the many questions that arose about her, her story was the most enjoyable in this novel. The second half of A Lion Among Men pieces together the significance of the allusive Clock of the Time Dragon, Yackle's purpose and what eventually happened to the Grimmerie. Fate is also a recurring theme as it was in the previous two novels and Maguire also begins to challenge unquestioned faith. There's a slight discord between Brrrs story and Yackle's and the two narratives simply don't mesh.
Because the characterization of Brrr was not as strong as I had hoped, I found myself longing to read more about Maguire's familiar characters such as Glinda and Liir. Although both are mentioned, neither appear in the novel and I had hoped to discover more about Liir's journey, especially after finishing Son of a Witch a few years ago for I desperate to read more. My biggest disappointment is that this novel did not continue what Son of A Witch established and where it left off. Maguire will hopefully continue Liir's story in future novels.
An enjoyable read as Oz is such a rich tapestry of people and places but perhaps sadly lacking in Brrr's narrative.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-10-17 12:53:18 EST)
  
                  Reader Reviews 1 - 29 of 29                 
  
  
  
  
  
  

Because the data used to generate this site come from outside sources, VeryWellSaid.com cannot guarantee the completeness or accuracy of the data.
Search VeryWellSaid™
Google
Web VeryWellSaid™
New subjects are added every week.
View Subjects Below by:
* Top Selling
 (click category name, left)
* Top-Rated Top Sellers
 (click 'Top Rated', right)
In the news...  
Dubai\UAE Top Rated
Influenza\Bird Flu Top Rated
Iraq Top Rated
Supreme Court Top Rated
All Books Top Rated
Arts Top Rated
Photography Top Rated
Digital Photography Top Rated
Digital Cameras Top Rated
Biography Top Rated
Business Top Rated
Management Top Rated
Marketing Top Rated
Sales Top Rated
Stocks Top Rated
Bonds Top Rated
Real Estate Top Rated
Trading Top Rated
Commodities Trading Top Rated
Time Management Top Rated
Starting A Business Top Rated
Children's Top Rated
Comics Top Rated
Computers Top Rated
PC Top Rated
Mac Top Rated
Programming Top Rated
Design Patterns Top Rated
.Net Top Rated
C# Top Rated
Vb.Net Top Rated
Asp.Net Top Rated
Java Top Rated
Python Top Rated
PHP Top Rated
Perl Top Rated
Javascript Top Rated
Ajax Top Rated
CSS Top Rated
Open Source Top Rated
SQL Top Rated
Databases Top Rated
Oracle Top Rated
MySql Top Rated
Sql Server Top Rated
IIS Top Rated
Apache Top Rated
Linux Top Rated
Windows Server Top Rated
Project Management Top Rated
HTML Top Rated
UML Top Rated
IT Certifications Top Rated
Cisco Certifications Top Rated
MCSE Top Rated
MCSD Top Rated
Cooking Top Rated
Italian Cooking Top Rated
Vegetarian Cooking Top Rated
Wine Top Rated
Engineering Top Rated
Entertainment Top Rated
Health Top Rated
Nutrition Top Rated
Dieting Top Rated
Sex Top Rated
History Top Rated
Military History Top Rated
British History Top Rated
Middle East History Top Rated
Land Battles Top Rated
Naval Warfare Top Rated
Air Warfare Top Rated
9/11 Top Rated
Terrorism Top Rated
Home Top Rated
Mortgage\Home Equity Loan Top Rated
Cars Top Rated
Car Buying Top Rated
Sports Cars Top Rated
Cat Top Rated
Humor Top Rated
Horror Top Rated
Law Top Rated
IP Law Top Rated
Legal History Top Rated
Fiction Top Rated
Oprah's Book Club Top Rated
Medicine Top Rated
Cancer Top Rated
Stroke Top Rated
Heart Disease Top Rated
Fertility Top Rated
Diabetes Top Rated
Pharmacology Top Rated
Back Problems Top Rated
Menopause Top Rated
Thyroid Top Rated
Pain Top Rated
Organic Chemistry Top Rated
Immune System Top Rated
Mystery Top Rated
Nonfiction Top Rated
Outdoors Top Rated
Running Top Rated
Radio Control Models Top Rated
Guns Top Rated
Parenting Top Rated
Divorce Top Rated
Professional Top Rated
Reference Top Rated
Religion Top Rated
Romance Top Rated
Science Top Rated
Physics Top Rated
Chemistry Top Rated
Astronomy Top Rated
Psychology Top Rated
Science Fiction Top Rated
Sports Top Rated
Teens Top Rated
Travel Top Rated
USA Top Rated
Europe Top Rated
France Top Rated
Italy Top Rated
England Top Rated
China Top Rated
All Books Arts Biography Click Here For An A-Z Index Of All 213 Best-Seller Subjects Business Children's Comics
Computers Cooking Engineering Entertainment Health History Home Horror Humor Law Fiction Medicine Mystery
Nonfiction Outdoors Parenting Professional Reference Religion Romance Science Sci-Fi Sports Teens Travel
In Association with Amazon.com

Cache miss
(not cached)