Oprah Book Club #62
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Sort customer reviews by: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Show All Reviews on Page
Hide All Reviews on Page
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Oprah Book Club #62 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Amazon Best of the Month, June 2008: It's gutsy for a debut novelist to offer a modern take on Hamlet set in rural Wisconsin--particularly one in which the young hero, born mute, communicates with people, dogs, and the occasional ghost through his own mix of sign and body language. But David Wroblewski's extraordinary way with language in The Story of Edgar Sawtelle immerses readers in a living, breathing world that is both fantastic and utterly believable. In selecting for temperament and a special intelligence, Edgar's grandfather started a line of unusual dogs--the Sawtelles--and his sons carried on his work. But among human families, undesirable traits aren't so easily predicted, and clashes can erupt with tragic force. Edgar's tale takes you to the extremes of what humans must endure, and when you're finally released, you will come back to yourself feeling wiser, and flush with gratitude. And you will have remembered what magnificent alchemy a finely wrought novel can work. --Mari Malcolm
Book Description Born mute, speaking only in sign, Edgar Sawtelle leads an idyllic life with his parents on their farm in remote northern Wisconsin. For generations, the Sawtelles have raised and trained a fictional breed of dog whose thoughtful companionship is epitomized by Almondine, Edgar's lifelong friend and ally. But with the unexpected return of Claude, Edgar's paternal uncle, turmoil consumes the Sawtelles' once peaceful home. When Edgar's father dies suddenly, Claude insinuates himself into the life of the farm--and into Edgar's mother's affections. Grief-stricken and bewildered, Edgar tries to prove Claude played a role in his father's death, but his plan backfires--spectacularly. Forced to flee into the vast wilderness lying beyond the farm, Edgar comes of age in the wild, fighting for his survival and that of the three yearling dogs who follow him. But his need to face his father's murderer and his devotion to the Sawtelle dogs turn Edgar ever homeward. David Wroblewski is a master storyteller, and his breathtaking scenes--the elemental north woods, the sweep of seasons, an iconic American barn, a fateful vision rendered in the falling rain--create a riveting family saga, a brilliant exploration of the limits of language, and a compulsively readable modern classic. Double Life, with Dogs: An Amazon Exclusive Essay by David Wroblewski Continue Reading Double Life, With Dogs Praise from Stephen King "I flat-out loved The Story of Edgar Sawtelle, and spent twelve happy evenings immersed in the world David Wroblewski has created. As I neared the end, I kept finding excuses to put the book aside for a little, not because I didn't like it, but because I liked it too much; I didn't want it to end. Dog-lovers in particular will find themselves riveted by this story, because the canine world has never been explored with such imagination and emotional resonance. Yet in the end, this isn't a novel about dogs or heartland America--although it is a deeply American work of literature. It's a novel about the human heart, and the mysteries that live there, understood but impossible to articulate. Yet in the person of Edgar Sawtelle, a mute boy who takes three of his dogs on a brave and dangerous odyssey, Wroblewski does articulate them, and splendidly. I closed the book with that regret readers feel only after experiencing the best stories: It's over, you think, and I won't read another one this good for a long, long time. In truth, there's never been a book quite like The Story of Edgar Sawtelle. I thought of Hamlet when I was reading it, and Watership Down, and The Night of the Hunter, and The Life of Pi--but halfway through, I put all comparisons aside and let it just be itself. I'm pretty sure this book is going to be a bestseller, but unlike some, it deserves to be. It's also going to be the subject of a great many reading groups, and when the members take up Edgar, I think they will be apt to stick to the book and forget the neighborhood gossip. Wonderful, mysterious, long and satisfying: readers who pick up this novel are going to enter a richer world. I envy them the trip. I don't re-read many books, because life is too short. I will be re-reading this one." |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Reader Reviews 1 - 50 of 364 Next | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Review Date |
Review Rating(5 High) |
Review Helpful to: |
Customer Review | Reviewer Info |
Permanent Link |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Reader Reviews Below Sorted by Newest First | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-30-08 | 5 | 0\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Absolutely loved the book!
The love and friendship between Edgar, Almondine and the other dogs was unforgettable and touching! Great, great writing on the part of Mr. Wroblewski. Edgar is an unforgettable character, who you really cant help but fall in love with throughout the book. His dog Almondine is one of a kind, dogs like that are something very special. All the dogs in the book are special. Dog lovers, any dog owner that has ever felt a overwhelming connection with their pet, read "Edgar Sawtelle"! Wonderful book, so glad I finally took the plunge and read it. ** Author David Wroblewski spent 10 years writing "Edgar Sawtelle", 10 years, WOW!, well worth it** (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-30-08 | 3 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
If you want Hamlet, read Shakespeare. If you want Buck, read Jack London. If you want a great story for a LONG, cold weekend by the fire, read David Wroblewski. Is Edgar Sawtelle meaningful literature? I don't think so, it won't withstand the test of time.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-30-08 | 3 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I just finished this book and I'm really glad it's over. The first feeling I had of the book was John Steinbeck. Poignant but depressing. I enjoyed the book, but the ending had no resolution. That Claude died didn't even get me a sense of closure. I know authors write the story that is inside of them but this one hurt way more then it entertained. Would I read it again? No! Would I read a sequel? Only if I felt there were answers to my questions instead of more questions.
He is definitely an author to watch in the future. His magic with words and the ability to make it "real" can only grow and improve. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-29-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I selected to read this book because it was an Oprah selection and I wasn't disappointed. David Wroblewski is a great story teller who know how to use words to bring you into a story. Set in Wisconsin with an unusual main hero, it holds your interest for all of the 576 pages. Loved it!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-29-08 | 1 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This book was given to me to read by my boss. This was the ONLY reason that I made it past the firts 30 pages. This book has no point and just when you think you are making it to a story it changes direction and that soryline is killed. You think if you could just make it to the end there would be a point but the end was worthless. Nothing explained and nothing solved. It was a serious waste of time. I will never trust an Oprah book club book ever again.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-29-08 | 3 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I should have known from the opening page of the Prologue that this was to be heavy and depressing. It was. Nevertheless, I had to keep turning pages. But it is not Hamlet that seemed to guide me here, it was Kipling and the wondrous Jungle Book. Edgar is our own speechless American Mowgli. Raised by dogs and threatened by the tiger Shere Khan. The book kept me crying.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-29-08 | 1 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I purchased this book as an audio download for $21.00 +. What a TOTAL waste of my money and time. I am so mad at the author and Oprah. Thank goodness there are so many on this site that agree. I don't feel so crazy. I just could NOT believe the ending. I was sure there was a problem with the download. Not until I played the end again and clearly heard the reader saying "You have each the end of this audio" ....I wanted to through the ipod out the window. If any of you have heard from Oprah about this I sure would like to know what in the hell she was thinking. I will never believe her again.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:35 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-29-08 | 4 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This book captured me. I enjoyed reading about the dog breeding and training. The hardships that Edgar went through made a great story. I really enjoyed this book until the Poison section. Then the author got sloppy and rushed along. The ending although unpredictable was horrid. Why lead the reader to such hope for Edgar and then end it in such a sad depressing state? I would read this author again. I hope he considers his readers in his endings for any subsequent books. I would read this book again just for the first 3/4 of the book. This story has kept with me, so it is definately a good story.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 12:04:36 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-28-08 | 2 | 2\3 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The most boring 562 pages in recent literature. I should have stopped after the first few pages but I kept expecting it to get better...it didn't. If it had been only 200 pages (and it should have been) my response would be the same. The writer can write but where is his story (same tired, Biblical theme), his sense of drama and most all, abilty to develop characters. 150 pages in the woods with 3 puppies stealing food from cabins...come on...yawn!!! The story should have been about Lucy, the Mum, NOT about Edgar. Her motives would make a much more interesting study.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 02:17:50 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-28-08 | 3 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This book grabbed me from the start. I loved the writing and the sense of place, and the role of dogs in this novel. But by the mid-200 page point, those good things didn't seem to be enough. Not much was happening. And then with the first big death, it was as if I were reading a completely different novel. Between mysticism and far-fetched plot turns, things happened, but I wasn't sure it was an improvement. And the end was bizarre, a little confusing, and not satisfying. Another issue: each chapter was told from the point of view of a different person (or dog). I liked that, but felt manipulated when I found that they hid key facts from the reader. I liked Edgar, the protagonist, as well as the dogs. And I enjoyed the writing throughout. There's a lot to like here, and a lot not to like. I liked it more than I didn't.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 02:17:48 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-28-08 | 3 | 2\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I listened to Edgar Sawtelle as an audiobook. It's a 21-hour and 45-minute listen, which took me several weeks to finish simply because it was just not compelling enough to reach for. I did enjoy parts of the novel. The relationship with the dogs and the development of a dog with the characteristics envisioned is intriguing. The parallels with Hamlet provided the potential for additional depth, but also allowed the characters to become predictable and flat. There were many characters that just weren't developed enough (despite the length). For me, the ending was a disappointment because it felt like a cop out. After spending so much time listening to the book, I expected more resolution.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-30 02:17:48 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-27-08 | 2 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
STORY BRIEF:
The story takes place on a farm in Wisconsin in the 1950s through 1970s. Trudy and Gar have a son Edgar. The family breeds and trains dogs who are extremely smart. Edgar can hear but he cannot speak, so he communicates with his parents and the dogs using sign language. REVIEWER'S OPINION: Since Oprah liked this book, I thought I'd give it a try. I enjoyed much of it. I think the author is a wonderful writer with his descriptions and characters. But, I hated the ending! It was horrible, sad and depressing. I was so upset, I quickly searched for something else to read to put me in a better mood and try to forget. If the author had chosen a different ending to be heartwarming, fulfilling or happy, I likely would have given it 5 stars. I wish the author would do a rewrite. Evil can exist and do damage within a book which includes a happy ending. Most of the books I read are romance novels because they guarantee a happy ending. I need to stay in that genre, but once in a while I will try something else. DATA: Story length: 562 pages. Setting: 1950s and later in Wisconsin. Copyright: 2008. Genre: human relationships fiction and mainstream fiction. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-29 05:50:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-26-08 | 4 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I just finished Edgar Sawtelle's story with relief this morning. I had begun listening to it on CD as I drove back and forth to work. Considering that the drive is less than 20 minutes per day, I picked up the book (actual words on pages) when I was about 2/3 of the way through because I simply had to move the story on along. I couldn't listen fast enough. I had to know what happened to Edgar and the dogs.
I found the story to be beautiful though painful. The opposites in life come to mind as I contemplate the complexities of what I've just been through with Edgar... Love and indifferent selfishness. Honesty and dishonesty. Good and evil. Happiness and sorrow. Family togetherness and lone survival. Strong and weak. There were 3 times in the first 2/3 of the book that I said I could not continue listening because I could not bear what might be coming. One afternoon, I sobbed all the way home from work as I listened to the story. I'll never forget Edgar and the Sawtelle family. I'll never forget the beautiful stories about the loyal and faithful dogs. I have joyfully shared my life with dogs, and I felt that the dogs' souls, unconditional love, and intelligence were more aptly captured in this book than in anything I've ever read. Am I glad I read this book? Yes, very glad. At the same time, I'm very glad to set it aside and have it completed. I'm glad I didn't miss it and will definitely recommend it to others. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:13 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-26-08 | 2 | 0\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I picked this up because of the reviews, the jacket was intriguing and I just love dogs. After I finished it I was angry. The ending ruined the whole book. I won't put in a spoiler but I'd just like to say that there were many more possible endings that would have tied together all that had happened in the book. The author chose a terrible ending with no meaning whatsoever. The only reason I gave it two stars is because of his relationship with the dogs - that was cool.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:13 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-26-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I really loved this book. This was the best book I've read in a long time and I wish the Sawtelle dogs were real because I would buy one so fast. :) I loved the character of Edgar in this book and his experiences with his home, family, and dogs. I think it's an interesting mix of an almost ordinary, routine life with alot of mysterious things that happen. This book had alot of things I love to read about- survival and the outdoors, dogs, growing up. I was just really intrigued by this book and I didn't want to like it because my mother pushed it on me, but I did love this book very much. I hate that it ended.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:13 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-26-08 | 5 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The writing is beautiful, really, really beautiful. The story is detailed and compelling. Once I had read a couple of chapters, it was hard to stop. And if, like me, you love Shakespeare and really love Hamlet, this book will be a great joy. I know Shakespeare's Hamlet backwards and forward and have studied it and seen every film ever made. I attend as many celebrated theatre productions as I can. And yet-- this book is a revelation. This book provides a backstory of Hamlet, with inspired detail and motivations of character that even truly inspired productions of the play can not provide. Like Shakespeare, Mr. Wroblewski, even working in novel form and with much detail, does not spell everything out for the reader. Parts of the plot are described from a dog's point of view or otherwise impressionistically, but the alert or astute reader will figure out what is going on. Unlike Hamlet, the reader gets deep inside the characters; the depth of their emotions nearly crushed me. This novel is heartbreakingly sad. "Edgar Sawtelle" a work of pure genius and I only wish it were longer. I wanted more. Once Fortinbras comes in and takes back his country, the story's over. But I did hate for the novel to end.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:13 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-26-08 | 3 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Edgar Sawtelle never quite delivers. This isn't apparent for the first 2/3 of the novel as the story develops and the artful language and tactile sense of place pull you in and keep you engaged. Unfortunately, the the return of Claude to the family sets loose the myriad of untold stories that litter Edgar's Wisconsin Woods like old dirt tracks, tracks that peter out with a gnarled apple tree and a broken down stone fence. They eventually leave too many questions unanswered.
I am not opposed to the fantastic but the visitation of ghosts is too contrived in this case and never satisfies or is sustained. Further, Claude is too cookie cutter in his resident bad guy role. Is it Hamlet with a good measure of Cain and Abel? I don't know but I read it all the way through and I wanted to like the story as much as I liked Edgar and Almondine. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:13 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 2 | 0\3 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
the book was well written, but just dragged on and on....not sure what all the hype was about. I kept reading the book hoping that something interesting would happen, but was ultimately disappointed at the end of the book and I felt that I had wasted my time on a book that I didn't enjoy.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 5 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This wonderful book had me at "hello" . I couldn't put it down... a richly told story about a beloved mute boy intertwined with an unusual and fasinating family business. But its much more than that.. I cant wait for Mr Wroblewski"s next book.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 2 | 2\3 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I'll admit out front I bought this book because of the hype and the Oprah pick. I loved the first half of the book (and it's a big book) - and then it just stopped for me. The writing got diluted and drawn out. I found myself skimming pages where, for the first half, I had savored every word - every page. And the ending?????? I just don't know what he was thinking. I don't even know what he was trying to get us to think. It was just so mumbled together, without clarity - leaving alot of questions. I agree with some of the other reviewers who said why draw the book out for so long with pretty useless details only to slam through the ending like, whoops, gotta get this thing over and done. I hated the ending.
I had recommended this book to some family members when I was first getting into it - and I actually emailed them back after I finished to change my review with them. I wouldn't waste my time reading it again, nor would I recommend it - and that's unfortunate because I really did enjoy it for a long way in. If the whole book had continued on the course it was started with it would have been a winner all round. I just don't know what happened mid way through. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 5 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
What a great story! Not a fast read, but one that you savor and that will haunt your thoughts long after you're through. Brilliant, realistic characters and setting. The plot is familiar and enthralling.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Edgar Sawtell was one of the many books on the list of a book club that I belong. Usually, the books are boreing and I believe that several of the members of the group have their "choosers" broken. But Edgar Sawtelle was WONDERFUL. It had a beginning, a middle and an end! The characters were real and emotions flew off the pages. I will definately recommend it to others.
J. Korte (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
About 100 pages into this book....love, love it. while there is no earth shattering event occurring, this is just one well-written book. I care about the characters and want to move forward so that I can see how the story unfolds. Highly recommend!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:15 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-25-08 | 3 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I was smitten with this novel- to the point that I became sleep deprived as I tried to read it at any possible time in between kids and job and home and husband. Dave Wroblewski has a spare, evocative style that drew me in and kept me transfixed. I honestly didn't see the Hamlet connection- I haven't cracked Hamlet since high school, so that was no help to me. I think the best word to use is frustrated- I loved the beauty of the prose, I loved Edgar and Henry, I feared for Gar and Trudy, I hated Claude, I suspected the doc and wanted to see and touch the dogs with an almost visceral need. But then almost everyone dies, even Almondine-agh! I HATED that part. Maybe I'm just too middle-class sports mom, and not intellectually ready for this novel, but I wanted a resolution so badly- PLEASE explain this to me!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-28 07:45:13 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 1 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This is definitely a disappointing book. Read Hamlet for the same story set in a different country with a better plot and much more interesting characters. This pretentious imitation will break your heart when you realize that you have wasted a dozen hours reading a book that never comes together at the end. I have seldom felt so cheated after finishing a novel.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 4 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Full of symbolism that will take a long, long time to fully comprehend and digest, this book is wonderfully written. The one terrible drawback is the ending, but since it is based somewhat on "Hamlet", then the ending is more understandable. I'm glad that I didn't know beforehand about the "Hamlet" parallels, because if I had, then I would not have invested so much of my time and energy in reading such a lengthy. albeit intriguing, book.
And most of the book is definitely worth reading. It's just the last part of the book is so unsatisfactory on a certain level...most of the characters in "Edgar Sawtelle" deserved better (not suggesting a shallow conclusion, but a deeply satisfying one more dissimilar to "Hamlet"). Since so much hype has been tossed about "Edgar..." being a "Hamlet" tale, then I doubt it will have the same influential power on an emotional level for readers in the future that it would have had had not the "Hamlet" parallels been bandied about so, spreading like wildfire, amongst a great many people (here on Amazon for example) this first year of it being published. This book is so much bigger than just a retelling of Hamlet, though, as it also has maybe even a prophetic voice to it in several areas. I would probably recommend it (with a little ambivalence) to most adults and older teens, and I might throw in the condition that they maybe shouldn't read it near any holidays they celebrate. I'm glad I read it, but do feel drained from the experience. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I, too, am struggling to resolve the choices made by the author at the end of the book. I, too, don't understand why there seem to be so many unanswered elements. I'm frustrated. I feel let down. However, I haven't been haunted by the beauty and characters of a book like I'm haunted by those in Edgar Sawtelle for quite some time. I haven't found myself replaying some of the plot points or character development of a novel to such a degree in a long time. A cynic will argue that flaws in storytelling have led to what I feel now. I might argue that the choices are deliberate and effective, if mysterious. In the end, it doesn't matter, because the book captivated me. Thoughts on nuances of the story and reasons for the ending only help to solidify my relationship with Edgar Sawtelle. I once had a dog with certain behaviors I struggled for the life of me to understand, but I cherished my relationship with him nonetheless. Perhaps that's a fitting reason why, to me anyway, the "dog story" of Edgar Sawtelle is one that I cherish.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Brilliant and totally believable. This is a coming of age story that pulls you in and doesn't let go until the end. The author sets a rich scene for the story to take place and it is not without riveting drama and tragedy. Jack London's Call of the Wild comes to mind as does J.D. Salinger's Catcher in the Rye. I have the Kindle version and spent 10 days reading it on my way to work. Almost missed my stop was so engrossed.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 2 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This book is way longer than it should be. The descriptive narrative goes on and on and on. You're afraid to skip any of it because there may be a "clue" that will make sense later. Entirely too much written on training the dogs -- hundreds of pages it seems -- and entirely more detail than necessary to explain why the dogs do what they do in their important roles in the story. I was upset that Almondine had to dye, but at the end realized she had to to be able to come get Edgar. But it was so very sad -- she should have been alive when he returned and they could have died together in the fire as she tried to save him.
I agree with other reviewers on the many threads left unresolved. A really weak ending. Where were the dogs going? I thought maybe to Henry (the Henry part of the story I thought was the best reading). I'm glad Claude died in the end but did Trudy and Glen ever find out the truth about Gar's death? Why did Gar tell Edgar to find Hachiko? THAT was the message he chose to leave his son with??? How about "I love you" or "Claude killed me". And in the end there was no importance to this at all. Also no importance of the vet owning part of the business. And I think it would have been just as good a story if Edgar could TALK. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 1 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I found the book quite disappointing, especially with all the hype. Poorly written, inaccurate, poorly researched in every single area (especially dogs and dog training). I'm discouraged to see how many people thought this was good writing. Too many rambling, strange, ridiculous discussions that never get connected to anything. Loose ends, no character development, pedantic, plodding.... and those are the best things I can say about it, frankly. The guy needs an editor!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-24-08 | 2 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Didn't know this was an Oprah Book when I ordered it or else I would have taken it as a warning. On more than one occasion I stopped reading the book but returned to it hoping it might get better, it didn't. Although the author is a fine wordsmith his character development is sorely lacking. The novel fails to expand on any of its character's and leaves one wanting. As I approached the end of the book I expected the author to tie the characters and story together into some discernable patchwork but it remained puzzling and, in the end, disappointing. The Hamlet plot was obvious and unoriginal, especially when the author failed to take it in any direction. Note to author, you should have either stayed true to the Hamlet plot or taken the reader in an original direction which made sense. Note to reader, pass on this book and take the Oprah label as a caveat.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 2 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The author is a gifted writer. He paints a beautiful picture of a Wisconsin farm and is able to make you feel the intesity of his relationships. However, the plot is frustratingly incomplete. Many paths are taken and none of them merge. His talent becomes wasted when you ask at the end "What was the point?". I don't need Disney endings or clever twists. I just hoped for a well put together story that left you with a satisfied feeling when you closed the book. You won't find it here.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 4 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
There is a section of this story where Edgar is traveling, and traveling with his dogs. It just seems to go on forever. It is however one of those books that you don't want to put down. Once I realized the Hamlet theme was in play, I really did not want to get to the end. Still, worth reading.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 1 | 0\4 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I put in the order. It was acknowledged. The next day I received a cancellation order with no explanation.
I would never use this merchant again (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 2 | 2\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I am the type of reader that really paints a portrait of the characters and setting when I read a book. Wroblewski, certainly is the kind of writer that does the same... the only problem is he easily shatters your images all at once and without a second thought, leaving the reader to pic up the pieces of what they thought was real, without even an explanation. I actually was angry when this book ended.. I felt like I was built up over and over only to be broken down again and again.. I was left wishing that I had closed the book when MY
picture was complete. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 2 | 0\3 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Another Oprah hype! I usually stay away from her books, but got duped into buying this one. Will not fall for the hype again!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 2 | 2\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I began reading this book three weeks ago, and I have finally gotten about half way through it. It is an interesting premise to the story, but the author has used twice as many words as are necessary to tell an otherwise good story. I hope to finish this by the time my book club meets on January 19!
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 1 | 0\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I couldn't stand reading it but continued hopeing it would get better...the reviews were so good. It only got worse..and the ending HATED it.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:18 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 1 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This was one of the s-l-o-w-e-s-t books I have ever read.
I did not see what all the fuss was about. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 3 | 0\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I'm a big reader but I'm not sure about Edgar Sawtelle. I was eager to read it and received a copy as a gift. The initial story was quite interesting, I'm a big dog lover and have serveral so I was attracted by the subject matter. However, the further I read the more frustrated I became. At one point a friend asked if I was enjoying it and I said, "Not really, I'm angry with Edgar and having a hard time continuing." I plodded through to the finish and was disappointed - not that a happy ending is required but....
I'll read it again in six months and see if I have a better reaction. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-23-08 | 2 | (NA) |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
First of all has no one noticed this book is a poorly written version of Hamlet almost literally?! I got a feeling it was quite a bit like hamlet when Edgar ran off into the woods but though "No he wouldn't just totally rip the plot off of Shakespear, that would be insane." All the major plot lines in the book are mirror images of Hamlet. Man kills brother (with poison) Man gets with brothers wife, Son runs away into woods to plot revenge, Large dramatic event, everyone is dead, literally or emotionally.
I thought it was rather confusing how Edgar could seemingly see ghosts, or spirits... I really didn't feel this was a book that had that much of a place for the supernatural, it was interesting with Ida because she was mysterious, but out and out talking with and seeing ghosts and having visions, some of which had literally nothing to do with the plot and had no reason to even be in the book, was bizzar and seemed out of place. Because this was billed as a "mystery" I thought maybe the twist was he really was crazy and something totally unrelaited was going on, or some sort of twist like the movie The Villiage, because it was honestly the only thing I could think of. I was wrong there was no mystery other then "Did the ghost tell the truth?" which frankly doesn't warrent a mystery in my oppinion. I thought the portrayal of the dogs was at least interesing while he was in the woods, although I thought the scenes from Almondine were strange and much of her interactions confusing especially in the beginning where she kept asking things around the house what the mystery was, I'm still not sure what she was asking about. Also I thought the descriptions about the dogs somewhat vague in comparison to the tedious detail everything else was explained in. For example, you are just given the general color and breed of the dog "some type of shepard" but later in the book the author spends almost an entire page explaining what the garbage inside a shed looked like, literally garbage. The only character I truly liked and found quirky and interesting, because he was a side character and didn't expect to learn everything about him was Henry. For much of the book I thought Edgar was an overly dramatic, possibly insane teen aged boy who was simply refusing to deal with reality. Trudy I thought was cold and somewhat pushy and bossy. Gar you don't really learn much about other then he liked to stand outside during storms. Claude, I was particularly unimpressed with this character. There was NO reason or explination for why this man was in anyway so manipulative, we were given no motive. Several times it was mentioned the reasons were in the past and the other chracters didn't know what they were, everytime you thought it was being explained it simply went off onto some new topic revealing nothing. In short if you want to read a book that will have you bored to tears and confused and leave you unsatisfied, this is a great book, especially if you love Hamlet. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-26 06:05:19 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 3 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Beautifully written - but I am an animal lover and it was very, very hard for me to always be waiting for the other shoe to drop. As much as I felt the author's intent to show Edgar and his father and mother's love for their dogs, I also knew (from the first foreshadowing/preface page of the book) that any minute a dog could or would die, be harmed, mistreated or neglected. This won't be a problem for most people, but as someone who anthropomorphises - I felt the dogs were strong characters in the book and deserved better. I literally could not finish this book once I saw the writing on the wall (which was soon after Gar left...), This was my first "kindle-book" and I was sad not to be able to finish the experience. I have NEVER not finished a good book. This is a first.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:28 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 3 | 2\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
What a wonderful read and a group of characters that tie you in to a story with the most unfortunate and ill-perceived ending. I, as other reviewers, do not mind a tragic ending, but too much of the novel's mystique that carries you through is left unanswered and unfinished. I am truly unsatisfied after a starting a book that seemed to be off to a great start.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 5 | 1\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I am not an avid reader but a friend recommended this book because we are both dog lovers. I really enjoyed this book & it is a book that I shall treasure and share with others.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 5 | 1\3 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I bought this book at the recommendation of the Oprah Book Club. I haven't completely finished it yet, but I'm at least halfway through and it's a wonderful book, wonderful story and I don't want to say more about it other than I have thoroughly enjoyed it so far. You can't go wrong with this one.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 1 | 0\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
As a lover of dogs and wonderful dog stories, and of teenage adventure, even as an adult, I cannot recommend this book to anyone except someone willing to completely overlook the plot and revel in the descriptions.
This is a ripoff of Into the Wild, and Call of the Wild. It's character development is completely missing, except with regard, perhaps, to the dogs. It is technically inaccurate, having Henry in possession of a car left outside his barn,that is one of the more valuable collectors cars out there. And perhaps the biggest dissapointment of all, is wading through page upon page of excessive poetic description and narrative to come to one of the worst endings of any book I have ever read. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 3 | 0\1 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
It was a great story with wonderful hidden gems. But, the incessive detail, that had no baring on the story, was tedious.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 1 | 1\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I can't imagine how this book got ANY 5 star reviews. The author can write words but needs to learn how to tell a story. The ending left you scratching your head. What happened to the dogs and Trudy? The characters were never really developed. I should have been sufficiently warned. It was an Oprah book club pick. I never like any of her picks.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 2 | 1\3 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
I too was taken in by the hype and stellar reviews of this book, however after reading it I'm no longer impressed. I can appreciate the writing style of the author and I found the story compelling. But it is so full of symbolism and unexplained happenings I found myself lost a good bit of the time. The ending is such a disappointment, with out giving anything away it left me deflated. So many parts were left dangling at the end. I would have loved to have a few of the stranger parts explained in more detail. Much of the book is left for the reader to interpret the meaning of the events. In my opinion, skip it and wait for the movie.
(Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 11-22-08 | 3 | 2\2 |
| Reviewer | Permalink | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This book should come with a warning: May cause severe depression. Not to give anything away, but this is NOT an uplifting story. I consider myself relatively literate (as a Russian history major I read many of those equally unhopeful classics) and I agree with the other reviewers who say that this story, while exquisitely, almost poetically, phrased, starts in middle and never gets to a real end. Storylines start and stop, seemingly randomly, with no real resolution or even explanation, making this a somewhat frustrating read. And despite the real, raw and undeniable talent of this author, the ending, which I don't want to give away, seems almost as lazy as the "it was all a dream" premise employed on soap operas. It's like he took us so far down the road and then didn't know where it went after it was clear there was no going back. I wasn't looking for a happy, all-loose-ends-tied-up-neatly, happily-ever-after conclusion but the forgotten/abandoned plot points were glaring to me and hindered my overall reading experience, irrespective of whether I "agreed" with the authors choices for his characters.
I will say it's not a difficult book to consume--despite its length and high quality prose I finished it in about three days--but I can't say I see the utter genius of, say, a Wally Lamb, which seems to me like what this author is being touted as. (Review Data Last Updated: 2008-11-24 05:50:27 EST)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Reader Reviews 1 - 50 of 364 Next | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||